• Link to X
  • Link to Instagram
  • Link to LinkedIn
Marina Jones
  • My Thoughts
  • What I’m Reading
  • About Me
  • Contact Me
  • Home Page
  • Click to open the search input field Click to open the search input field Search
  • Menu Menu

Tag Archive for: fundraising

Eat butter & get drunk: How to raise money for a cathedral

March 15, 2024/0 Comments/in Thoughts/by admin

Building, maintaining and rebuilding cathedrals and monasteries was an expensive and ongoing business.

Here are just some of the ways in which funds were raised from the tenth century to the fifteenth. Many of which we see today in various forms for capital campaigns, or other appeals, and others we can adapt.

  • Eat Butter

What have you given up for Lent?

If you had permission to break that in exchange for a donation would you?

During Lent, the faithful were to abstain from meats, dairy and eggs, which mean that the townspeople of Rouen could not enjoy Normandy butter. However, if they made a donation of 6 deniers Tournais to Archbishop Robert de Criosmare’s fabric fund for the cathedral they would be let off their Lenten discipline and permitted to eat butter.

The fundraising by this exemption was so successful that it raised enough money for the tower of the cathedral – which is known to this day as the Tour de Beurre (Butter Tower) because of where the funds come from (and that is made of local yellow limestone that has a buttery hue!)

Butter Tower at Roeun
  • Sponsor a window, a pillar, a figure, a chapel, a candle, an arch, a day’s labour, a year’s labour

Basically you can sponsor anything.

We like to be able to know what our contribution did – to say to others or just to ourselves ‘I did that’. The options within cathedral buildings were endless – arches, windows, chapels, figures on a portal (at Notre Dame they originally planned to have 28 chapels but the popularity of chapel support locally meant they had over 50 chapels were installed – how’s that for donor dominance!).

Windows proved to be one of the most popular ways that individuals or local trades could show their support and the sponsor is often shown in the window – so we see windows from fishmongers, clothshearers, leather dresses, masons and church builders.

Shoemakers guild contribution celebrated in stained glass at Chartres

(Although, the cathedral in Tournai complained about the ‘pompous trimmings’ of the excessive donor led art projects that supported additional decoration rather than the building of the cathedral – donor dominance even then!)

It was not just physical capital items that were supported. People also made donations to fund positions – for a day, for a week, for a year. Again demonstrating that every contribution can be attributed to part of the project. It is easier for our brains to process and understand – 3s pays for one day’s labour than to grasp the complexity and cost of a whole building project.

Nowadays capital campaigns allow people to do everything from name a building or a room, but also the smaller and more tangible items from a light switch to a toilet brush, well as supporting the salaries of posts.

And the church were creative and offered lots of opportunities to credit donors – from donor books, coats of arms on walls, pictures in painting and windows and many more. In Strasbourg each week they held an elaborate ceremony on Sunday after the high mass reading out the names of the donors to the fabric fund and writing their name in the Liber Donoatiorium (donation book) For more about donor recognition in churches see this earlier blog about donor recognition or the IWITOT (I wish I thought of that session) about donor recognition on SOFII’s website.

Although as well as crediting donors, these memorials could be used to name and shame. In the donor book of Milan it lists that ‘all the braiders of Milan except Giorgio Coiro‘. So poor Giorgio is forever immortalised as the one that did not pay (maybe don’t try this with your donors!)

Donating money to have the bells rung for the living or the dead could also grant you an indulgence. Indulgences could be offered, reducing the amount of time the donor spent in purgatory, and hence placing them nearer to heaven. But it was a core thing that needed to happen and be paid for – a great way of funding those core costs.

How can we chunk our campaigns into chunks so that people can know that they have supported a specific thing to happen?

How can we recognise and celebrate those gifts in creative and aligned ways?

  • Gamification and competition

In Milan in the 1380s what galvanised the capital campaign for the cathedral was some healthy local competition. One local neighbourhood, the Porta Nuova gate started a weekly collection. The next week the Pavia Gate started, with the aim of being seen more generous than their neigbours. And the competition spread.

How can you introduce fun and friendly competition into your campaign?

  • Tap into supporter identity
Milan Cathedral

The competition between the Pavia Gate and the Port Nuova above highlights the importance of hyper local identity.

Every supporter has several identities that reflect who they are (or how they want to be seen as their ideal version of themselves) your fundraiser message can connect with these identities – as a Christian, as a Catholic, as a proud city resident. But identities go deeper and hyper local. In Milan there are dedications and donations from ‘the young men of the East Gate‘ – this is not just an affinity to the city, or to the cathedral, or saint, but to the local area –

Where are the identity triggers with your donors? How do you provide segments that reflect true and deep connections?

  • Calendar highlights

Church campaigns used high days and special holy days to enhance campaigns. For example, Assumption-tide was used as a way to galvanise campaigns. The relic quests (which you read more about here) often worked between Pentecost to Assumption (partly because of the weather).

Most religions have seasons when charitable giving is particularly encouraged like Ramadan or Lent, that can be used as times to encourage giving. Or anniversaries (of your founding, of a specific event) can be used as a hook for a campaign.

How can you use dates and moments in the year to bring life to your campaign?

  • Be organised

Milan cathedral had an organising committee of 12 nobles, 9 canons, 16 citizens and 3 lawyers (and 20 notaries were busy copying out the bishops letters to diocesan clergy requesting support). One hundred local citizens also oversaw the work being done checking the quality of materials and work being done. Fundraising is not a lone task of the fundraiser working away on their own or with their team it needs the whole organisation to be involved in supporting success. It also requires planning and strategy.

Milan was built relatively quickly there are other examples when fundraising stalled because of plague, war, the Crusades or other political upheavals. The most successful campaigns had a visionary champion who believed in the project and excited others and got them organised.

The Canterbury register of donors opened 8 years before the building began!

Have the structures and processes in place – budgets, targets, ROIs, LTVs are important and you need the staff infrastructure to support success.

Who are your champions that can excite your supporters and your staff?

  • Gifts in kind

As well as financial donations, gifts in kinds of bricks and stones from other were also welcomed.

“If I were a shepherd I would bring a lamb” (from the carol In the Bleak Midwinter)

Devotional gifts also included a horse, a basket of cherries and an egg.

How can you encourage gifts in kind of the things you need?

  • Authority figures

In 1171 the Bishop of Norwich sat on the cathedral entrance to accept donations from the faithful. We are influenced by the messengers that ask for gifts, but also get an extra warm glow from making the donation to someone important.

  • Leadership gifts

In a capital campaign you always want a leadership gift – a big gift from a significant person – with authority and integrity to lead the way for others to support. Often in the Middle Ages this would be the Bishop or the Cathedral chapter.

  • Going once, going twice ….

People donated and bequeathed items to the fabric funds and these were put up for public auction to raise funds. These included gowns, boots, towels. jewellery, furs, daggers, helmets, gauntlets, and silver slippers. These seem to have been sold at a commercial rate rather thank like an auction generating over the odds prices as a way to support the charity.

  • Employee involvement and the Ikea effect

The challenge for fundraisers can be finding an appropriate and useful way for partners to be involved in your project – it can be painting, gardening, volunteering at an event but it tends to be an important way that the employer can demonstrate their impact and charity credentials and build teams.

This was not a problem for our medieval counterparts, as using free labour was part and parcel of building a cathedral. Various guilds and confraternities would come and offer free labour for a day or a week.

As well as burly people to get the job done, this also has an added effect of creating a deeper senses of engagement and commitment to the cause. The Ikea effect means we value something more if we have been involved in its creation (like the flat pack furniture) – the involvement of the armourers or the drapers had a vested interest in the success and use of the cathedral by donating their time to building it.

How can you get people involved in the cause to make them feel more involved? They may not be able to dig a foundation but how can they feel connected to making things happen?

  • Donation boxes

Donation boxes are nothing new and recorded in the Temple in Jerusalem in the time of Jesus.

In Milan in the fourteenth century, a donation box was placed next to the work building the cathedral encouraging more donations.

There is always an argument about how effective they are for actually gathering donations, or whether they are more useful for the mere exposure effect of the need (and there is more about their power and persuadability here). Perhaps they were particularly effective on relic tours, when after an emotive sermon two trusted men would solicit donations.

  • In memory giving

Giving in memory of someone we love can elicit a bigger and more emotional gift. In Milan we see some early in memory giving for ‘by Francischino Carcano for the soul of Sempliciano Limit who formally resided with him‘.

How can we use the emotions we feel for other people (dead or alive) to inspire gifts?

  • Anonymity offered

Not all donors want their name, their guild or their crest displayed it is important to be able to offer donors the choice to be anonymous – this example from Milan ‘offered on the high altar by a certain illustrious and exalted lady who would not be named’

It is always a good option to allow your donor’s the choice to remain anonymous.

(But sometimes anonymous can be an excuse for even more credit and this clip from Curb Your Enthusiasm about anonymous donations)

  • Location, location, location

Toulouse Cathedral made use of its location on the route to the St James of Compostela pilgrimage route so its donation boxes did particularly well.

  • Use the power of celebrity

When Pope Innocent IV stayed in Lyon 1245-51, the lagging cathedral fabric fund had a huge boost. Using the power of celebrity can help increase donations to the campaign – with the pope you have a celebrity and an authority linked to your cause.

  • Make the most of bad things happening

Archbishop Richard le Scrope was executed in 1405 for his part in the Northern Uprisings. Pope Innocent VII excommunicated those that had been involved in his trial. He was buried at York and viewed as a saint and martyr by some. York had been lacking a saint, and the veneration of Scrope’s relics increased revenues and donations.

(As an aside – he is one of the traitors, along with Westmoreland, in Shakespeare’s Henry IV Part Two – where he is definitely a traitor not a saint)

  • Myth making and reality

There is an enduring myth that Henry II built Poitiers cathedral. He is depicted with his wife and children in the central Crucifixion window. In reality it was a much more communal effort with his contribution, the bishop, the chapter, other parishes, burghers and local craftspeople. After capital campaigns, certain myths develop about how it was funded and by who.

  • Questions over whether you can accept money from Prostitutes of Paris

Having a policy and concern for repetitional risk in accepting donations is nothing new – generally the church disapproved of usury (taking interest) but the clerics of Notre Dame had some interesting discussions about whether to accept donations from the guild of prostitutes – read more on concerns about tainted money below:

https://twitter.com/Philliteracy/status/1463986789757161476?s=20

Make sure you know who you will accept money from, and a have a plan on how you assess their suitability

  • Get drunk

From the tenth century at least the use of church ales was common place to help raise much needed funds. These were social occasions with much beer, dancing and games. Parishioners allocated members of the parish to brew the beer which was sold at a premium to raise funds. These ales were also used for raising support for members of the parish who had fallen on hard times and were a form of horizontal philanthropy and mutual aid. These ales were also used to help newly married couples – which is where the word ‘bridal’ (bride-ale) comes from.

Although this practice as open to abuse and sometimes people just got drunk and claimed it was ‘for charity’.

Social fundraising like gala dinners and balls continue to be a tried and tested way to raise funds with people paying over the odds/commercial rate to support a charity and/or enjoy the social time.

Make fundraising fun and social and create events where people can come together to support you

And some practices that we will not be adopting

  • Confiscating property of heretics and those of other faiths (especially Jews)
  • Enforced taxes and tithes and contributions from other parishes
  • Using the confessional (in Strasbourg) to stress the importance of donation
  • Priest needed to be at the drawing up of wills so the importance of gifts for salvation could be stressed (in Toulouse in the thirteenth century). In Strasbourg in 1283, the city stopped all bequests to the church because of the undue pressure put on the dying and the protestations by heirs.
  • Arresting donors that don’t pay up – Michel de Lucy (son of the King and Archbishop of Bourges) was compelled to pay to restore the cathedral by his father the king. When he did not pay, he was arrested in Paris and forced to pay.
  • In St Luke’s Gospel it says “for which of you desiring to build a tower, does not first sit down and count the cost, whether he has enough to complete it” – words not taken on board by many medieval cathedral builders!

In 1544, Emperor Charles V wanted to donate a new rose window to Utrecht cathedral but they had to refuse as they could not afford the installation costs.

So what can we learn from medieval cathedral building schemes

  • How can you get people involved in the cause to make them feel more involved? They may not be able to dig a foundation but how can they feel connected to making things happen?
  • How can we chunk our campaigns into chunks so that people can know that they have supported a specific thing to happen?
  • How can we recognise and celebrate those gifts in creative and aligned ways?
  • How can you use dates and moments in the year to bring life to your campaign?
  • Where are the identity triggers with your donors? How do you provide segments that reflect true and deep connections?
  • How can you encourage gifts in kind of the things you need?
  • Who is receiving the gifts?
  • How can we use the emotions we feel for other people (dead or alive) to inspire gifts?
  • Make sure you know who you will accept money from, and a have a plan on how you assess their suitability
  • Make fundraising fun and social and create events where people can come together to support you
  • Who are your champions that can excite your supporters and your staff?

References

‘How a Cathedral was Built in the fourteenth century’ by E Bishop (1898)

‘Two thousand years of disreputable history’ by Redmond Mullins

‘Gold Was the Mortar The Economics of Cathedral Building’ by Henry Kraus

‘Conviviality and Charity in Medieval and Early Modern England’ Judith M Bennett Past and Present 1992

‘Financing Catherdral Building in the Middle Ages the Generosity of the Faithful’ by Wim Vroom

https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/shoemakers.jpg 280 602 admin https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.png admin2024-03-15 21:09:482025-09-07 13:56:48Eat butter & get drunk: How to raise money for a cathedral

Look! Fundraisers on the Bayeux Tapestry

March 11, 2024/0 Comments/in Thoughts/by admin

This scene depicts the funeral procession of Edward the Confessor (later a saint) on the way to Westminster Abbey. Look closely and underneath his funeral cortege are two men carrying what appear to be collecting bags for donations.

It was common from the tenth century onwards to tour saint’s relics to raise money for cathedral fabric funds, and for two men to collect the money from the crowds who had worshipped and venerated the relics and listened to emotive and inspiring sermons. Hence, the translation of Edward the Confessor’s body to the Abbey could have been used to raise funds for building his shrine and the enhancing his saintly reputation.  Therefore, academics have suggested that this is fundraising in action – and in tapestry form!

What was a relic quest?

A relic quest was a reverse pilgrimage – instead of pilgrims travelling to see the saint’s relics – the saint was toured to them. The relic quest usually involved:- 

  • The relics of a saint being toured locally, regionally, nationally or internationally in a reliquary (a specially designed ornate receptacle)
  • Veneration of the relics by the local people
  • Stories of the miracles performed by the the saint and/or their relics
  • A stirring sermon detailing the power of the saint, sinful nature of humanity, need for repentance and penance, and the need for funds and the project (often a cathedral or monastery building project after a fire or another disaster) 
  • In exchange for donations to the cause, indulgences could be offered, reducing the amount of time the donor spent in purgatory, and hence placing them nearer to heaven

From the Council of Rome in 1078 there was a duty for all the faithful to donate at mass, on feast days, pilgrimages and other holy days. There was a Christian duty to give alms; the care for  Christ’s body on earth, the church, was an important area where alms were encouraged.

Reliquary of St Foy

Although fundraising was the primary purpose of these tours, they were also used to cement the reputation of the saint locally. Depending on the needs they could be time limited to secure funds to (re)build the cathedral or monastery or become annual calendar events.

Who did this fundraising?

Those on these tours were given the title questor seeking alms (donations) for religious purposes – this is one of the earliest titles for fundraisers. Originally these questors were canons or friars associated with the church or monastery conducting the building project, but as early as 1094 there were specially paid priests (unconnected with the institution) for these fundraising expeditions. 

The preaching and collecting donations model was so popular that in the eleventh century, there were special preachers employed to raise funds for other areas of work, notably for the hospitals run by the cathedral or monastery – special preachers known as vulganter vociarus pardoner had special permission to preach and collect one Sunday a year for hospital funds. 

They were contracted by the Bishop or Chapter and made contracts about how the funds earned were donated – 1/3 to the pardoner and 2/3 to the cause was common. But some times (as today) these contracts were subcontracted out.

Antonies, raising funds for the hospital of St Anthony the Abbot in the 1200s received contracts to cross diocesan boundaries to raise money. St Anthony Abbot is often shown with a pig, a Tau cross and a bell on a stick – the bell was there to attract donations.

When relic quests began they were mainly focussed on church building and conducted by canons and friars. By the fourteenth century, given their success at raising funds they were used for raising funds for hospitals, the poor, bridges, lights and a wider variety of causes areas. (For example, St Anthony’s Hospital in London received £500 of its £550 income from questors.) This could be seen as mission creep, or the success of the mechanism and the nascent professionalisation of fundraising. With this those asking for the funds stopped being ordained ministers or from the clerical class and laymen were recruited to collect. Then as now, good questors (fundraisers) were hard to find, but they were paid for their work. There were serval models – some were paid an annual fee and others were paid up to a third of the collection. Questors as a profession ran in families and they were expected to police the behaviour of other collectors.

1215 – Regulation of how fundraising could be done 

Innocent III

These relic quests became a popular way to raise funds but there were concerns about abuses of power (and fake fundraisers) so in 1215 at the Lateran Council IV, Pope Innocent III decreed that all questors needed a licence from the pope and permission from the local diocesan bishop or king to hold a relic tour. These licences generally lasted a year.

Instead of stirring emotional sermons, questers had to read out a set letter as they solicited alms. This meant that the letters got longer (from 500 words to 2,000+) which included multiple asks for alms and donations. The letter would be read out and two worthy men would collect the funds (as we see above in the Bayeux tapestry).

It also included stipulations on what the questors ought to be wearing and how they ought to behave! No taverns, modest behaviour and clean and tidy dark clothes – they should not dress like wealthy people. 

The Lateran IV Council also tried to limit the indulgences that could be offered in exchange for donations – setting specific amounts of days remittance in purgatory for donations.  Indulgences worked as a powerful incentive for donations, but are definitely more at the transactional/ self interested end of the giving spectrum – rather than altruistic. Indulgences were pardons for sins, giving reduced time in purgatory for those that truly repented. Although indulgences did not strictly require payment, the physical paper proof of forgiveness of sines was proof of the transaction. Their use increased and became increasingly problematic throughout the centuries  (This is a gross oversimplification of a complicated and nuanced topic but to give a summary of the challenges and evolution of the issue and its problem.) By the fifteenth century the questors became known as pardoners (and the Pardoner can be seen and is mocked in Chaucer’s Canterbury Tales)

It was ever thus … a few medieval issues that we still see today

  • Repeat the ask – the twelfth century sermon preached at Amiens with a relic tour includes four asks for funds in the sermon. Repetition helps our brains process things more easily. The more repetition the faster we process. The more the ask is repeated – the more we are being primed to give – so it is important for our appeals to repeat the ask multiple times. Remember, donors are not paying super close attention to what we write or say – they skim read/selective hear, so a repeated message helps convey what we want them to do.
  • Not everyone agrees about charitable priorities, Bernard of Clairvaux said that the church collections and relic quests were too focussed on beautiful church buildings and not the poor in need (‘She dresses her stones in gold and lets her sons go naked’). There are still debates today about how philanthropic money should be spent and where it is most needed.
  • Fundraising is not always successful – in 1086 the Benedictine monks toured St Eusebia’s relics and lost money on the tour 
  • Fundraising is based in time and place and what is charitable and acceptable evolves. In the tenth century, indulgences were an unproblematic way to offer a spiritual reward to donors, but as the practice evolved they become more transactional, less philanthropic and much more controversial (A few decades ago, a charity sixth form slave auction that might have run as a fundraiser, or accepting a collection from the local hunt (which the RNLI recently turned down), but what is socially, morally and ethically acceptable changes and evolves with societal norms). Fundraising for pirates ransoms used to be common – see more here. Fundraising practice, like what is charitable, evolves with time and place.
  • Who you take money from – the church would not take money that had been earned in certain ways particularly from usury (taking interest on loans) and prostitution. Nowadays your acceptance of gifts policy might meant that oil, tobacco, fur or arms dealers are not acceptable to your charity. What is ethically acceptable, like fundraising methods, evolve over time, but reputational risk has always been a concern….
  • Need for a strategy – Bernard of Clairvaux was concerned that church building projects should not be started unless the relevant funds were in place to complete the project.
Bernard of Clairvaux

What did these sermons say

Set words of a sermon for the reading out for alms from Amiens (blame Google translate, my school girl Latin is not what it was)

For as the Apostle says, we shall all stand before the judgment seat. We must receive Christ according to what we have done in our bodies, whether it has been good or bad the extreme mercy of the Messiah to prevent the works and to sow eternal ones in the earth, which By returning to the Lord with a multiplied fruit, we must collect in the heavens, firm hope and confidence holding, because he who sows sparingly also reaps sparingly, and he who sows in blessings, the blessings and reaps eternal life. Since then, for the support of the brothers who were in need of such things. At the confluence hospital, the facilities are not properly available, we advise your university and we are exhorted in the Lord and we have commanded you to forgive your sins, as far as good things a contributing to God, give them pious alms and acceptable charitable support, as by subsidizing them. Let your own poverty be consulted, and you through this and other goods which the Lord inspires having done this, you can reach eternal joys’.

And the Reformation changed all these practices.

So happy questing fundraisers!

Coming next … relic quests were just one way that cathedrals and churches were financed – find out how butter helps build a cathedral. Read more here https://marinajones.uk/butter/

References:

‘Relic Tours in England and France’ by Cristine Oakland (which includes quotes from my former professor)

https://kar.kent.ac.uk/77090/1/39Relic%20Tours%20in%20England%20and%20France%20%28c.1050-c.1350%29.pdf  

https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/detail1.jpg 304 362 admin https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.png admin2024-03-11 12:31:322025-07-25 16:38:04Look! Fundraisers on the Bayeux Tapestry

Cleopatra’s needle and donor pyramids

February 1, 2024/0 Comments/in Thoughts/by admin

Fundraising challenge: You have a donor willing to give you something you want, but you cannot afford costs associated with the project.

It’s happened for many of us – in order to secure the thing you want – you need another fundraising campaign.

This is what happened with Cleopatra’s Needle.

In 1819 when Muhammad Ali Pasha gifted the UK the obelisk known as Cleopatra’s Needle (which has very little to do with Cleopatra).

For 58 years the obelisk remained in Egypt, but then the land where the obelisk was stored was threatened, something had to be done. So a fundraising campaign was planned to finally bring it to England.

The negative risk of not doing something is a useful tool for any campaign – using the urgency of needing the funds before it is too late to drive action.

The major funding came from one individual – Sir William James Erasmus Wilson (a very solid Victorian name!) – a well-to-do dermatologist with a passion for Egypt. He contributed £10,000 of the £15,000 needed to bring Cleopatra’s Needle to London.

The remaining £5,000 was raised through a public campaign – made up of lots of small donations.

The main costs were needed to ship Cleopatra’s needle from Egypt to London and this was done in a 18 metre cigar shaped pontoon called The Cleopatra. On the journey during a storm the pontoon was cut loose to save the crew and floated around the Bay of Biscay for 60 hours before being rescued and delivered back.

Cleopatra’s Needle has now been on the north side of the Thames for 146 years – and Wilson’s contribution is recognised by a plaque which recognises his ‘patriotic zeal’ in bringing it to London but does not mention his financial contribution.

Donor Pyramids

Fittingly for an Egyptian artefact, the fundraising campaign conforms to the standard donor pyramid model. The model sees large lead gifts at the top of the pyramid, supported by many smaller gifts at the base of the pyramid. The Pareto Principle says that 80% of your gifts ought to come from 20% of your donors. In this case 75% from just one donor!

You want to secure the majority of your fundraising target and leadership gifts in this first private phase of the campaign. With a leadership gift of £10,000 in this private phase, you give confidence to the wider audience that the project will happen when your project becomes public.

This campaign represents a rather a top heavy pyramid with an over reliance on one major leadership gift. A more typical donor pyramid might look something like this:-

It is important to have lots of people you can ask – as not everyone will say yes (or say yes at the level that they are asked to support).

Being near completion also incentivises the public phase to help complete the target – when you get nearer your target and people have confidence it will be achieved, the speed of gifts often increase.

And did you know?

Inside the pedestal of the obelisk is a time capsule including a set of 12 photographs of the best looking English women of the day, a box of hairpins, a box of cigars, a baby’s bottle, a hydraulic jack and some samples of the cable used in the erection of the Needle, a portrait of Queen Victoria and a Bradshaw Railway Guide!

References

http://topicaltens.blogspot.com/2014/09/12th-september-cleopatras-needle.html

https://www.theguardian.com/news/2020/apr/08/weatherwatch-the-perilous-sea-journey-of-cleopatras-needle

https://www.museumoflondon.org.uk/discover/victorian-cravat-pins-and-cleopatras-needle

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cleopatra%27s_Needle,_London

https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/celo.jpeg 497 703 admin https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.png admin2024-02-01 23:27:232024-02-02 08:24:10Cleopatra’s needle and donor pyramids

Murder on the Dance Floor – Extraordinary How Potent Cheap Music is 

January 24, 2024/0 Comments/in Thoughts/by admin

Saltburn ends with Barry Keoghan dancing to Sophie Ellis Bextor’s 2001 pop hit ‘Murder on the Dance Floor’ – for those that remember it from 23 years ago it will have specific associations and memories – a certain bar, lifestage or nightclub (and for some it may have completely passed you by).

Our brains are wired to emotionally respond to music which is why certain songs have a power to transport us physically and emotionally to a moment – a university bar, a crush, a city, a holiday, a road trip, childhood, someone we love. Familiar music, especially music with vocals, causes a psychological response (increased heart rate & blood pressure) – music is wired to our memory.

And our brains are constantly rewiring and making and remaking associations to music, so ‘Murder on the Dance Floor’ may become newly associated for you with Saltburn, as well as keeping a trace of the former memories.  

Sound is one of the most powerful senses we have, but one often under used in fundraising. 

Listening to music can give you thrills and produces endorphins and activates the brains reward circuits. 

“Music does a lot of things for a lot of people. It’s transporting, for sure. It can take you right back, years back, to the very moment certain things happened in your life. It’s uplifting, it’s encouraging, it’s strengthening.”

Aretha Franklin

The power and embodiment of music can be seen in this former ballet dancer with Alzheimer’s hearing Swan Lake and recreating the steps

At the Coliseum we recently had Marina Abramovic’s opera project 7 Deaths of Maria Callas which used seven famous arias of dying sopranos to explore the life of Maria Callas. The first one was from La traviata – the aria at the beginning of the final act where a dying Violetta is contemplating her imminent death. For me, this 6 minute aria, was like a concentrated experience of the opera. Despite just having this extract, and not seeing the previous two acts, every time I saw this aria it moved me to tears as I could feel and remember the emotions I would have experienced watching the whole piece, and knew where we had reached in the plot, and what was coming.

Mood music 

The cues music can give us are subliminal nudges, that can impact our mood, but also our behaviour, how fast and what we eat, and what we buy.

Music with a faster tempo makes us eat faster, and people tend to spend more money and eat slower when jazz or classical music is played. Think about the ambient background music you might have in a restaurant – fast and pop for somewhere that wants to turn tables, and more mellow and chilled for a restaurant that wants to encourage you to spend longer, spend more and enjoy the experience. (Although music can also be used as a deterrent, a Welsh branch of MacDonalds plays classical music after 17.00 to deter anti social behaviour)

This real life experiment in an East Midlands supermarket shows how the background music has more impact that we might think it would

  • When French music was played 75% bought French wine
  • When German music was played 73% bought German wine

When asked about their choice of wine, and whether the music had impacted their choice, only one of those surveyed noted the impact. (North, A. C., Hargreaves, D. J., & McKendrick, J. (1999))

What does your brand sound like?

Brands use sounds, known as sonic branding, to help us readily recognise them:-

MacDonalds has ‘I’m lovin’ it’ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tfhlEP8LT4k and Intel has the ping https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-ihRPi4wcBY

Coca Cola used this image and the slogan ‘try not to hear this’ to evoke the sound of the fizz of the bubbles (there were also adverts showing a detailed close up of the ring pull being pulled back, and a bottle opener opening a bottle). The advert invites us to hear the remembered sound and trick our brains to almost hear it.

What does your charity brand sound like?

The RNIB has recently released  a sonic identity https://www.rnib.org.uk/about-us/sonic-logo/

But what has it got to do with fundraising?

We know sound (and taste/smell – think Proust and the madeleines) are some of the most powerful senses but unless you have the budget for a TV ad (or create a ‘scratch’n’sniff appeal) they can be underused in fundraising appeals (in direct mail or adverts.)

We know that we and our supporters receive information in many ways – that the words are only part of it, and that the real and imagined images we use have an impact – as does the weight of the paper, the design of the piece, the feel of appeal in the hand, the order we present information. We know that appealing to many of the donor’s senses can make our appeals more vivid and effective. So, we might appeal to donors to remember a sound (children crying) or imagine a future sound (children laughing), but we largely rely on the words and the visual of the design of the pack – letter, the lift letter, response mechanism, the call to action.

For someone working in opera and fundraising, the sounds created and remembered are key – the emotions they stir in audiences from the dopamine of anticipating what it will feel like to hear that music again, to the oxytocin of the emotional engagement with the story – music is so important. And not just the music, but the whole holistic and acoustic experience of the performance, of being together, with an audience, inside a theatre.  The hubbub in the bars before hand, the orchestra tuning up as you take your seats, the silent anticipation with the audience holding its breath before the curtain rises and the applause at the end.

How can we integrate soundscapes into an appeal?

  • How can we create appeals that bring more of the sound world – real, remembered or future created by the donor’s action into our appeals?
  • How can technology help us integrate and create an immersive sound world?
  • How could we use sound to provide a richer and deeper connection with our donors? To their memory? To their identity?
  • What segments of donors will this soundscape be most effective with?

I have some ideas that I am developing to try and find ways to test, gamify and play with sound in supporter communications and see if it can be used to enhance the communication and their connections.

https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/fTlCNdgFhcW1V5-OO8UV6xT-xw1k-LGXcpTIN_sgpSY.jpg.webp 576 768 admin https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.png admin2024-01-24 08:24:142024-01-24 08:24:14Murder on the Dance Floor – Extraordinary How Potent Cheap Music is 

5 More fundraising firsts and fundamentals from the Salvation Army archives

January 18, 2024/0 Comments/in Thoughts/by admin

1. Challenge events – raise a minimum to participate

You may have thought that raising £5,000 to walk the Great Wall of China or bungee jump off a bridge were newer inventions but it is something fundraisers have done for over a hundred years.

In 1902 the Young Helpers League of the Salvation Army had to fundraise and then present a purse with a minimum donation to attend an event at the Royal Albert Hall. 

2. Mircodonations before microdonations were a thing 

‘Grace before meat’ boxes encouraged small and regular donations throughout the day with a penny before each meal with grace.

Like rounding up at the till at the supermarket, or other shopping experiences, they offer a gentle and frequent opportunities to give.

3. Give yourself if you want to ask 

‘Make some definite sacrifice yourself as your soldiers are sure to reflect your conduct’

The Officer, 1893

The peer to peer ask is a powerful one – when someone like you asks you to join them in also making a gift it invokes a social norm and shows that they are committed to it too. 

If you want to be asking other people be a donor yourself. If you don’t care enough to give, in some small way, why should anyone else?

Also, being a donor to your charity (in whatever way you can) allows you to better understand the donor journey and what it feels like to be part of the supporter group, track the appeal and see when the letter or magazine lands on the doorstep and how quick and effective the thanking process really is.

4. Ethical products can also support mission 

In 1891, playwright George Bernard Shaw and Fabian Society member Annie Besant were amongst others were campaigning against the Bryant and May match factories and their use of phosphorus in match production. The match girls went on strike to protest working conditions and the use of phosphorus in matches which resulted in ‘Phossy Jaw’ (a painful deterioration of the jaw and teeth caused by the phosphorus used in the match production process). 

The Salvation Army created a new match factory that did not use phosphorus and produced matches with better pay and processes – these were called Lights in Darkest England and were more expensive to purchase than other matches. They were promoted as a way of supporting the ethical production but the factory closed down after a year.  

So not everything works – and it is important to fail fast if a new idea doesn’t work stop doing it.

How else can you give supporters a chance to live out and align with your values with other purchases?

5. Issues of ready cash & when to ask

William Booth preaching at a meeting

We might think the challenges are of cash giving are a modern problem. Post pandemic many shops and charitable donations only offer contactless donation opportunities.

But 140 years ago fundraisers were worrying about donors having cash on them and their ability to give at collection time.

“Well-to-do people seldom carry much money with them in their purses, and yet the best time to touch their hearts is under the mellowing influences of a meeting, when they will often give twice as much as they would when they get home, or under other ordinary circumstances’ 

The Officer, 1893

For more on the challenges of cash read here

How can we make it easy for people to donate if they don’t have cash on them? Or if they only have cash is only accepting contactless donations stopping them giving?

This also speaks to the best time to make the ask – when they are emotionally engaged and warm to the ask, when they have been inspired by your cause.

When do you ask donors for a gift? When you have ‘touch[ed] their heart’ are really inspired them or when they are in ‘other ordinary circumstances’?

(To read more about Salvation Army fundraising fundamentals and innovations read this article https://marinajones.uk/salvationarmy/)

https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/IMG_9403-3-scaled.jpeg 1838 2560 admin https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.png admin2024-01-18 09:11:232024-01-18 10:21:015 More fundraising firsts and fundamentals from the Salvation Army archives

Will you give like BP this year?

January 3, 2024/0 Comments/in Thoughts/by admin

In December 2023, BP announced giving £50m to support the British Museum.

In 1974, the Sackler family gave $3.5m for the new Sackler wing at the Met Museum  

What links these two headline gifts?

No, its not just the ethical concerns. 

The headline gifts highlight an interesting trend that mega givers sometimes deploy. The headline grabs the attention but the gift is paid out in instalments.

The BP deal is £50m over five years.

The Sackler support of the Temple of Dendur was over 20 years (and actually required the Met to take out a loan to support the cash flow of the project).

Former Sackler Gallery at the Met, NYC


What if we framed our own giving differently?

Instead of thinking about the one off gift, what if we thought about the multi-year commitment and the cumulative total. How we frame a gift is really important.


What if this new year you were asked to make a £5,000 commitment to a charity you cared about?

Your first reaction might be denial – I can’t afford that, that’s beyond me. But if we frame it differently – might you already be a £5,000 donor, £1,000 donor or more?

  • The £5 monthly donation you started 14 years ago makes you a £1,000 donor. 
  • The £3 a month donation from 23 years ago is over £1,000.

Which charities are already in that bracket for you?

Hyperbolic discounting vs goal gradient

These small monthly donations add up. Fundraisers often try and make small regular gifts salient, and anchor people to the small number e.g. ‘for just the price of a coffee a week you could save a life’. This is hyperbolic discounting – we tend to discount events that happen in the future and prefer to take a small amount of pain now (paying is painful).

What if we focused more on the goal and the pride or sense of achievement of reaching it? Each monthly direct debit would take us nearer to our goal.

  • Start a £75 a month donation (plus Gift Aid) and in 4 years and 6 months I becomes £5,000
  • Or start a £20 a month donation (plus Gift Aid) today and in 3 years and 4 months you will have given £1,000.

How might we celebrate those milestones for our donors? 

Some charities have special donor board that recognise cumulative gifts of £1m+, what if instead of celebrating the amount we celebrated the sustained duration of the gifts? A donor board celebrating those that have given consistently for over ten years, or a badge. Blood donation is brilliant at celebrating those anniversaries of donations made with certificates, badges and gifts to mark milestones. 

Today was the 50th anniversary for my blood donation. The hospital gave me some memorial items. Of course, it's not my goal. I started donating my blood in 1995 when Hanshin Awaji huge earthquake occurred. As of now, I regret that I hadn't done it in my 30s due to my busy days. pic.twitter.com/AJsczkU4Yk

— Roy Brown (@RoyBrow83928879) February 20, 2023

Can we celebrate donor anniversaries rather than our charity’s? 

Taking the ‘they are not your donors, you are one of their charities’ mantra, do we need to think about it being their anniversary with your charity and not yours that matters. My anniversary as a donor is more significant to me than the fact your charity has been around for 50 years or 93. Celebrating that I have been giving £10 a month for 10 years recognises my loyalty and commitment and enhances it. It makes my identity as a donor stronger. It makes me feel special and valued, -rather than just another donor.

This is a great example from Lisa Sergeant used for a special segment of donors that had been supporting Trocaire for 25 years – by celebrating the donor identity they increased engagement, response rate and income in this mailing and it had ripple effects going forward.

Quoted in ‘Change for Better’

So in 2024, where might you give like BP or Sackler?

  • How can you think about your 5-10 year commitment to a charity and that adds up to and might do?
  • And how can you celebrate donors giving over a longer duration more?
https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/IMG_9691.jpeg 1512 1156 admin https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.png admin2024-01-03 07:55:102024-01-03 07:55:11Will you give like BP this year?

Legacy brochures from 90 years ago

December 7, 2023/0 Comments/in Thoughts/by admin

What was included in legacy brochures in the 1930s? How did charities speak to their supporters about legacies?

In the Salvation Army archives which I recently visited there were two examples of legacy brochures from the 1930s.

Let’s look at the covers.

We have quotes from Shakespeare (left) and Shelley (right). This clearly speaks of a general knowledge of literature amongst the Salvation Army soldiers (even the RSC does not quote Shakespeare on their legacy page today!)

Having the date and the name of the person writing the will written by hand makes it feel personal, more authentic and a nudge to complete your own. The quill is poised ready for you to pick up and write your will. It is positioned in the correct place for a right handed person (the majority of people) to start writing making it easy for our brains to understand what is expected of us.

(Although be great to test the impact of a personalised pack like this with the potential pledger’s name on the cover …)

What is included and what would we still include today?

  • Case studies and examples of what a legacy has done in the past – this serves two purposes – one it gives social proof that other people have done it and it is a normal thing for supporters to do. It also serves to give an example of the impact of what a legacy can do.

In the 1933 brochure a case study details the Anna Wilson House which was established thanks to a woman’s legacy and talks about the difference it was made ‘During the six years since then more than four thousand women and children have enjoyed the hospitality of the Home and the benefits of a seaside holiday!‘ It includes a picture of the women and children on the beach enjoying the experience.

Legacy brochures continue to tell the story of the impact of legacy gifts and what they achieve for the charity.

  • List of legacies – There is a list of legacies received with the names and amounts of their bequests. This is a way of commemorating the donors and recording their names for posterity. It is also useful to demonstrate that this is a normal thing for Salvation Army soldiers to do.

I am not sure we would list the amounts given nowadays. And the legacy donor credits would not be in the marketing brochure but on a wall, a plaque, a tree of life as leaves, a programme, a book of remembrance (physical or digital). Having a place where donors (and their families) know that they will be credited is an important addition.

  • The statement ‘we would advise you to consult your solicitor’ – this is similar to what we’d find now, as the fundraising team are not always legally trained, and a will ought to be executed by a professional solicitor.’

In the 1893 issue of The Officer (Salvation Army monthly magazine) there are detailed instructions about how to complete a legacy properly as there have been cases when the will has been insufficiently witnessed to be legally binding.

  • Statistics on impacts of the charity and its work. There are pages dedicated to the work of the Salvation Army and what it has achieved and the need for its work.

Clearly, back then, as now, talking about the impact of your work is important.

  • Foreword by the current General – the General was the most senior figure in the organisation and wrote the foreword to the brochure.

Often we use the most senior person in the organisation like the CEO or Chair of the Board to be the authority figure talking about the vision and the need. They are someone well known to supporters, respected and trusted to enact the legacy gift.

  • The acknowledgement that talking about death is not easy ‘It is a common mental attitude to think every one mortal but ourselves…. The very thought of making one’s Will, for instance is unwelcome to many people. They connect it with hastening, somehow, the inevitable dissolution’.

This links to terror management theory (which was only proposed as a formal theory in 2015) which says that reminders of our death kick in a self preservation instinct that makes us deny, delay or distract from any talk of death. This is one reason why people don’t have wills as they cannot bring themselves to acknowledge and deal with their ultimate demise.

Not many legacy brochures now tend to be so up front in acknowledgment of this – they tend to focus on a celebration of life and looking back, looking forwards and saying thank you.

During internal training and when getting organisational buy in to promoting legacy giving this uncomfortableness does appear for some. However, people for whom death is more salient can be very up front about talking about funerals, death and legacies – it can be a self imposed fear by fundraisers.

  • Choosing where your bequest goes – there are two forms that allow someone to make a gift to religious purposes or to the social work of the Salvation Army.

Many charities today allow your gift in will to be directed to the area of the charity’s work that is most meaningful to you. Can you give the donors the autonomy to decide where their gift goes? Many charities try and keep the bequest wording as wide as possible as they don’t know where it will be most needed at the time of the realisation of the gift – but can you direct it to broad areas of work (like the religious purposes of social purposes) with a non binding condition on it.

  • Keep drip feeding the message – the 1886 Salvation Army annual accounts statement includes the standard words for a bequest. It is important to g the information they need to enact their will. It is also important to drip feed the legacy message throughout communications with supporters as you never know when someone will be writing their will – most of the time they are not writing their will so the regular drip feeding of the message means they might get the subtle nudge and reminder at the right moment and act on it.

Today a pledger might just need a the registered charity number to take to their solicitor – interesting to note that this predates this legal structure and the bequest instruction reads “I give and bequeath unto William Booth, the General of the Salvation Army … or other General of the Army for the time being, his successor, the sum of ”

Where can you continue to talk about legacies and their impact – it may the annual accounts and reports (or this may be where you list and acknowledge the bequests received). Can you continue talking about legacies in newsletters and supporter magazines, as well as targeted correspondence and events?

  • Confidential correspondence – ‘General Booth will always … treat any communications made to him on the subject as strictly private and confidential’.

Making a will is a private affair and many people do not want to talk about the details of their will with other people, The assurance of a confidential communication about this is important for donors – and many charities toady continue to offer this confidentiality guarantee.

  • Named contact – when talking about something so important and personal as a will it is important to have a named person to talk to. The General, William Booth is listed as the contact for soldiers wishing to consider making this gift.

Giving a name, personal email and phone number (and sometimes even photo) of the person who you will talk to about a bequest can reassure donors (rather than an anonymous legacies@charityname.org).

What is different?

  • Suggesting the amount – The Salvation Army brochure lists amounts of bequests and what they would be endow in death.

Not many charities do this today – with rising costs of inflation it is hard to guarantee what a particular amount might do. Suggesting an amount could act as an anchor and make potential donors feel if they cannot give at that amount their gift would not be appreciated. The counter to that is that without any amount donors don’t know what a gift could do!

  • Pledger stories – research has shown that hearing from current pledgers who are alive and made a commitment to a gift in a will inspires us. We react to seeing people like us who have had similar experiences and connections to the charity making this commitment. Many legacy packs invite donors to share their story and memories.
  • No Contact form – we want donors to contact its and tell us that they have made a gift. So supporters are invited to get in touch with the charity and tell them they have left a gift (or even that they don’t and won’t and to stop asking).
  • No Legacy circles – there is no suggested ongoing contact with these pledgers in the 30s. There is no ‘let us thank you in your lifetime’. For some supporters this continued contact and acknowledgement is an important part of the gift and allows them to deepen their connection and meet other like minded supporters.
  • No codicil or letter of wishes – donors not have greater flexibility and ability to add (or remove) you from their will!
  • Legacy is the dominant word and phrasing here – the term gifts in wills is often preferred nowadays and the term bequest or dislike actively disliked by some donors.
  • Living legacies – the 1933 brochure talks about living legacies. This seems to come in and out of fashion and is always a question for charity and the donor. When needs are so urgent and pressing it is best to have the money now? Is it best to give the money now and see the impact of the gift (and get thanked in your lifetime)? Or to wait until asets are realised on death and give then? With the climate emergency some donors are giving now to ensure that urgent action can take place?

The clock is set a 11.45 emphasising the ‘every minute vital’ message and that the clock is ticking. Often campaigns use the visual of a clock to reinforce the message that the time is running out to make a gift before a deadline. It acts as a powerful visual anchor.

Again like the legacy brochures at the top there is a handwritten note saying ‘I bequeath and give to the Salvation Army to be used and applied for its general religious purposes and …’ There is something about the handwritten notes which helps the donor imagine themselves into the situation and that it could be their will.

So not that much has changed in the last 90 years …

https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/IMG_9411-1-scaled.jpeg 2560 1920 admin https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.png admin2023-12-07 17:43:112024-01-09 13:16:22Legacy brochures from 90 years ago

A brief selection of charity merch from the archives

December 2, 2023/0 Comments/in Thoughts/by admin

So your email is probably bombarded with charities and various Christmas catalogues and ways you can support them through purchases gifts or Christmas cards.

The first Oxfam Charity Christmas card was in 1957 but the tradition goes back further than that

Designed by Leslie Durham

So a short festive look at some of the charity merch that you could have bought in times gone by and why it has an enduring appeal – for charities and donors.

Epistolary scandal novels (1799)

In the 1799, you could buy the sensational novel (price one shilling) entitled ‘The Magdalen or the History of the First Penitent Prostitute received into that charitable asylum with anecdotes of other penitents‘ (what a title!).

These were written in letter form and detailed the fallen women – in this case a clergy daughter seduced by a charming older man who finds herself abandoned. They perhaps veered a little towards the sensational and were enjoyed more for the scandal of the story than improving moral purpose.

You could also buy published popular sermons to support various causes.

Abolitionist Plates and Medals (1780s)

Abolitionist, industrial entrepreneur and potter Josiah Wedgewood created tableware to support the anti slavery movement. He also designed the anti slavery medallion which became a highly fashionable item to wear.

“ladies wore them in bracelets, and others had them fitted up in an ornamental manner as pins for their hair. At length the taste for wearing them became general, and thus fashion, which usually confines itself to worthless things, was seen for once in the honourable office of promoting the cause of justice, humanity and freedom”

The tableware and the medallion were sold to raise funds for the cause and Wedgewood donated directly to the cause himself.

Iron for Gold (1813)

This item doesn’t have a price and sits somewhere between a charity merch item and a donor thank you. During the Napoleonic wars Princess Marianne of Prussia asked the nobility to give up gold and it they were given iron jewellery emblazoned with ‘I gave gold for iron‘ and became the fashion of the court.

Typewriter ribbons, lampshades and much more (1890s)

The Salvation Army used modern printing technology for the best advantage. They turned attractive soldiers (members of the Salvation Army not real soldiers), fundraising events in New Zealand, the famous officers of the day into postcards to sell to raise funds.

Postcards depicting self denial effort
General Booth on a postcard contributing to the Self Denial Effort

The leader of the Salvation Army was the General and the founding General – General William Booth. General Booth’s image was on tea cups, crockery, lampshades, playing cards, glue, typewriter ribbons and everyday items with all profits going to the Army. His voice was recorded on photograph and recordings of him sold.

Salvation Army plate depicting General Booth
Salvation Army uniform and memorabilia including record of General Booth sold to raise funds

Sheet music, commemorative handkerchiefs and napkins (1899)

Rudyard Kipling’s poem The Absent Minded Beggar was set to music by Arthur Sullivan and became the UK’s first charity single raising for funds for soldiers returning from the Boer War. People bought the sheet music to support the war effort, but could also purchase the matching handkerchief (seen below).

Suffragette crockery (1909)

In 1909 The Women’s Exhibition used a suffragette tea service for the duration but then sold it to raise funds. Broaches and pins were also used to raise funds for support.

Why is charity merchandise so popular with us

For the charity it obviously raises funds and allows a donor to support in another (often additional) way. They may be a member but will also buy the tea towel, the mug, the baseball cap and the gin. It also offers the charity free advertising – if your donors are walking around with your tote bag or umbrella, or sending your Christmas cards.

But charity merch plays another very important role – from cups to typewriter ribbons or hankies it helps cement their supporter identity as part of your supporter tribe.Yes, the motive for the purchase may be blurred and they buy the item because it is pretty or practical but is also personal – a personal allyship with the cause. Like wearing a football shirt, a university scarf or a t-shirt with your favourite band on it – it is showing affinity and identity. Collecting and using the item reinforces their connection with your charity and a memory associated with it – perhaps with each use of the cup, the bag, the gin they are getting a microdose of dopamine (the happy chemical) and being reminded of the warm glow of giving to your charity.

For your supporter having your merchandise is a way of them signalling they are someone that cares about preserving art or fighting for justice – and literally have the t-shirt to prove it. 

How can help your supporters literally wear the t-shirt of support?

https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/cup-scaled.jpeg 2560 2560 admin https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.png admin2023-12-02 16:53:042023-12-02 16:53:05A brief selection of charity merch from the archives

Fundraising fundamentals – Red kettles, self denial & picture receipts

November 30, 2023/0 Comments/in Thoughts/by admin

The Salvation Army Christmas red kettles are perhaps one of their most well known ways of raising money and especially at Christmas time – seen on Friends, When Harry Met Sally and countless other shows. 

The famous Salvation Army red kettles first appeared in 1891 when a former sailor and Salvation Army Captain Joseph McFee was thinking about how to raise funds to provide the poor of California with a Christmas dinner. He remembered how when he was a sailor at Liverpool Docks there was an iron kettle called ‘Simpson’s Pot’ for donations for the poor. He used this idea to set up a kettle and with the slogan ‘Keep the Pot Boiling’ – a tradition was born that lasts to this day. 

Looking back to when Joseph McFee came up with this idea we can see a whole wave of fundraising innovation and inspiration from the Salvation Army. I recently had a rather fundraising history geeky trip to their archives to see some of them for myself. And here are 10 fundraising fundamentals from the archives of the Salvation Army.

Background

Founded in 1865 as the East London Christian Mission by William and Catherine Booth. It sought  to bring physical and spiritual salvation to the poor and destitute – and is often known for the 3Ss – Soup, Soap and Salvation. A radical reassessment of mission involved a rebrand turned the mission into the Salvation Army in 1878 when William Booth became the first General led to rapid growth and expansion with work staring in America and Australia in 1880. The reshaping of it into Army with a General as a leader, army officers and members as soldiers also involved a radical overhaul of its fundraising need as it expanded beyond its East London base and sought to bring that salvation to the world.  The Salvation Army was one of the first international big brand charities.  In 2023 it has over 1.7million members and is the largest non-governmental provider of social services in the US and is active in over 133 countries. 

Alongside the red kettles the other most notable campaign is the annual Self Denial Fund. Which began in 1886, when John Aiken Carleton could not donate a big gift, but decided to give up puddings and donate the money saved to the Salvation Army. This became an annual campaign which all soldiers were asked to participate in and recruit others to donate to funds at the same time. And again, continues to this day. 

What fundraising fundamentals do we see at work? Why do they work – now and then?

1. Use the latest technology

Fundraisers have always adopted and used the latest technologies to raise money in new and creative ways. So now we might be thinking about how AI, ChatGPT or the latest social media viral video can be used to gamify our fundraising. 

In Victorian times it was no different. The Salvation Army grabbed the opportunity presented by the new photolithography machine. Basically this was an early form of photocopying and it allowed you to make cheap and effective copies of appeal letters. 

So that the appeal letters that they sent looked like they were handwritten to you from General and Catherine Booth, the two leaders of the Salvation Army.

General Booth 1894 Self Denial Fund appeal letter
The photolithograph captures his handwriting and brings the personal touch

Seeing the copies of the letters in the archives it is hard to believe that they are not really handwritten – they are a blue inky colour (it is tempting – but I didn’t- to lick your finger and smudge it to see it is a really written in ink). So they do really look like a personal appeal. 

We are all attracted by the novelty and using the latest technology can make our appeals go further and also entice donors to the cause.

We also pay more attention to handwriting rather than just printed text – it stands out and catches the eye and therefore the attention of our supporters. 

Making a direct appeal letter stand out 

Underline – emphasising something and making it stand out more for the reader. Like any good direct mail fundraiser General Booth uses it sparingly to add stress to phrases and sentences. 

The lines Booth underlines in the 1894 appeal are ‘Will you unite with us in this work?’ and ‘Please look at it’ referring to the leaflet associated with it.

The use of the underline also helps make it easier for the reader to process the information. We tend to lazily scan words and the underline makes us pause and pay attention. It breaks up a big block of text.

2. Donor centric language – it is not about ‘we’ the charity but about ‘you’ the donor

General Booth was an early adopter of using donor centric language (perhaps he went through an earlier draft and changed the ‘we’s into ‘you’ as fundraisers are schooled to do).

The 1905 letter says 

“But you are more than an heir of heaven and a traveller to the eternal city. You are a partner with me in the fight. You are a soldier of the cross …. You will not disappoint your general”

There are notably more ‘you’s in the copy than ‘we’.

Donor centric and emotive language that really draws on the reader’s religious and personal identity and connection to the cause. How do you make it about them? And why they should support you?

3. Cases for support: Appeal to the heart and the head

We all know you need a different case for support for each donor. 

The Salvation Army Self Denial leaflet gets around this by printing each of the areas that you could be concerned about – ‘People who believe in the Old Bible’, ‘People who hate the Drink’,’ People who love Children’ and ‘People who pity the Poor’. Each of these then presents a case and detail of the work in that area. 

Cases for support
Statistics and impact

If you are not so visual, or attracted by these cases, there are also detailed statements of impact, reach and numbers for the more quantitative data driven donor!

Sometimes you need to write a special case for supporter for a very distinct target market, in  1904 a female Salvation Army officer in Sweden wrote appeals in Latin to flatter her male undergraduate students 

Cognosce te scopum forum

4. You want to run a good campaign – you’d better be organised

If any charity could organise with military precision it was the Salvation Army. They utilised their military structure, branches and publications to regularise, systemise and approach campaigns and fundraising with rigour. 

The annual Self Denial Fund was the most dominant campaign which they through all their administrative might behind.   

  • Be prepared with the print
Self Denial Appeal 1895 Front Cover
Fold out inside to detail what given up and contribution
Need and impact

Printing had become cheap and easy so there is collateral for every part of the campaign. There were promotional leaflets for Self Denial Effort with attractive picture covers, printed forms inside to detail what had been given up and what raised and impact statements.These were supported by forms for fundraisers, envelopes and receipts.

Self Denial Fund envelope 1919
Self Denial Fund envelope 1927

Have a campaign plan

Day by day guides were published in The Officer monthly magazine about how to prepare and what to do each day of Self Denial Week  e.g. Thursday reads ‘The week is now drawing to a close. Look up weak ones, visit best friends, take out band with some novel contrivance’

There are strategic plans to draw up how much you will raise from each mechanism – envelopes, pictural receipt books, salary sacrifice. And suggestions to put the previous years total prominently on the wall so you can check in on how you are performing against target. 

And even plans that divide up each road in each area and how many houses it had and how many collectors were needed for door to door collections in each road.  

Promotion is key

The Officer is full of guidance of how to make the most of advertising your campaign. Deliberately borrowing from commercial marketing techniques suggestions include using empty shops, a hand cart, sandwich boards and sample press releases are included. They even suggest going to factories with a collecting tin on pay day to maximise donations.  

5. Build the thank you into the campaign and make it memorable (or even collectable!)

We all know how important it is to say thank you to our donors for their support and leave them feeling appreciated.

Each collector was armed with a receipt book that they could give on receipt of a donation – some were plain white receipts and some were pictural. Each year the images on the picture receipts varied. In 1892 the receipts all had a sticker that could be fixed on of the celebrated Salvationists – it feels a big like collecting football stickers or Lego cards that you need to get the whole set. Interesting to note the majority of these do not include the word ‘thank you’ – they just say ‘received one shilling’. 

1890 Receipt
Picture receipt originally 1896 but crossed out and reused in 1897
1892 Receipts – collect your favourite Salvationist

(How dull most modern receipts are)

These receipts were replaced by thank you book marks which are described in the appeal packs as to be left with donors as their ‘medal for caring.’

How do you build the thank you into your campaign planning? How do you make it memorable? You can imagine these pictural receipts displayed in homes. How do we continue the joy of giving with the thank you?

6. Value every gift

The guidance for the Self Denial Fund recognises that not everyone can give cash. It suggests that soliciting fundraisers even accept postage stamps to support the campaign saying ‘Many will give one or two postage stamps when they will not give money’. 

Every little helps.   

How can you value any contribution to your work?

7. Don’t forget to ask those who you help 

In 1891 an ‘Out of love’ campaign targeted former residents of Salvation Army homes, inviting them to give a one penny a week back to repay some of the ‘toil, the care, the love and the expense which has been so freely and gladly expended on them’. If they gave enough they were gifted a Bible and their name was inscribed on the roll of honour. 

Often charities shy away from asking those that have benefitted from the charity’s work to be involved in supporting it (not so much in the arts where audiences are asked.) This provides a small but meaningful way for those that have been impacted by the work of the charity to help. Giving back and saying thank you are often strong motivations for giving. 

Whose life has changed because of your charity’s work and how can they be invited to join the supporter family?

8. Make it easy for people to do what you want them to do 

The concept of self denial can feel too vague for some, so in 1889 a ‘Special Hints for Self Denial’ pamphlet was produced listing all the practical ways that you could participate. Examples were given of donating one day’s salary, buying less expensive food, put off paying for new clothes, walk and not using public transport. The funds could then be donated to the Salvation Army. It makes it easier to do. 

Vague concepts put an additional cognitive load on our over stretched and lazy brains and too much to think about decide stops action. Make it easy for your supporters to know how to help.

How can you make it easier for them to do what you want them to do?

9. Show don’t tell 

Postcard used to raise funds 1890s depicting General Booth making a Self Denial Fund donation

In an early ‘show don’t tell’ example we have a postcards of General Booth and other Salvation Army soldiers donating money into a Self Denial Fund box. Literally showing people what you want them to do. 

(the earliest example of a self denial campaign was in 1209 when the canons of Angeirs Cathedral sacrificed the cost of feasts to support the capital campaign to build the cathedral)

How can you show your donors what you want them to do?

10. Mission matters but so does money

“there is nothing next to definite spiritual work, of greater importance that raising finance’ 

The Officer 1893

This mission is important but cannot be completed or attempted without the funds to back it up.

Has anything changed? 

So from a 1891 idea for a red kettle that is still used today (hey, if it ain’t broke, don’t fix it). 

Much in fundraising doesn’t change 

  • The need for good planning
  • The importance of thank yous
  • It is about them – not about you the charity 
  • Make it easy for your supporter to know what to do
  • Show don’t tell
  • Don’t forget those that benefit
  • You cannot do good without money to do it with 

It all feels very modern, and the changes that were made in the late Victorian period are seen in many ways that we fundraise today and in the innovative spirit of fundraisers. 

The Salvation Army saw itself in direct competition with consumer market and so used the same tools and marketed “compassionate consumption”(Roddy, Strange and Taithe). They, along with other emerging brand charities like Dr Barnado’s, certainly embraced the advances in technology and the rise in mass fundraising communications. 

They themselves recognised in 1893 the change that they were part of  

“.. few organisations have been so successful in raising money as ourselves. This has been largely because we have set about it in a systematic, methodical, businesslike manner …. Our methods for raising money have been and are almost innumerable, the military nature of our organisation enabling us to act together with a uniformity and precision which to others would be almost impossible”

The Officer, 189

This ‘systematic, methodical, businesslike manner’ has ripples today in how we approach fundraising.  The approaches introduced by them and others like St Barnado’s advanced the professional practice of fundraisers and have been proved to be psychologically powerful and effective tools for persuading people to give money to support much needed work. 

  • Did the ‘compassionate consumption’ approach mark a change in fundraising? 
  • Did the adoption of commercial marketing and promotion raise more money? 
  • Did the impacts of consumer culture, capitalism and technology change the essence of how fundraising was conducted? Away from the personal, dutiful gift, to a more mass produced and marketed machine which by its nature provided a more transactional (picture receipt anyone?) approach?  Or in a industrial capitalist society were we always heading towards that?  

Background on why this blog came about 

After reading ‘The Charity Market and Humanitarianism in Britain 1870-1912’ by Sarah Toddy, Julie-Marie Strange and Betrand Taithe and learning all about all sort of interesting fundraising activities and methods I visited the Salvation Army archives in Denmark Hill. Interestingly the fundraising was all run from the Public Relations office and they have an archive of early fundraising examples from the 1880s through to more modern times. Fascinating to see. Like many archives it is a bit patchy and speaks to the issues of how we preserve and archive what is important. 

https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/ETKNds2XgAErlJT.jpeg 414 649 admin https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.png admin2023-11-30 21:04:032025-07-25 16:34:54Fundraising fundamentals – Red kettles, self denial & picture receipts

The history of fundraising is more complex than our simple narratives  suggest 

November 9, 2023/0 Comments/in Uncategorized/by admin

Fundraisers and historians have at least one thing in common. They both love a story. For the fundraiser, stories allow them to get a case across simply and effectively – eliciting sympathy, driving action, empathy, and action preferably in monetary, form.  

Conferences are full of workshops on how to tell better and more compelling stories. We know it can be more effective to keep the story simple, info-lite, and negative-but-solvable. Yet the complexity of the needs that our charities try to address, and the efficacy of the solutions offered, do not fit into a neat narrative or case study. Too much information can overwhelm supporters, slow down the decision-making processes, and make our asks less effective. The donor can be placed in the centre of the story as the hero who can provide the solution so we keep it simple, and focus on the story.  

For the historian, stories are about condensing complex social, cultural and political movements of people, power and place into compelling narratives. We want a narrative arc. We want to link an assassination here with a coup there (wider history not fundraising history), or we want to trace the origins of this war in the peace treaty 20 years beforehand. We know it is more complex, and that correlation is not causation, but to make it understandable we tell it as a shorthand of events and moments. As the Cambridge history professor  John H Arnold  says: “History is to society what memory is the to the individual.”  

“When we come to explore to the history of fundraising, we often grasp for the unusual – the fundraising ‘firsts’ – and try to weave them into a narrative arc (the fundraiser’s need for a story dominates!).” 

Both fundraisers and historians stitch together the elements of the available facts that serve the story’s purpose – to raise funds; to try and tell us what has happened and how we got there.  

Is it any wonder, then, that the history of fundraising to date has hooked on to a ‘great story’ – the origin myth of the evolution of fundraising being led by Charles Sumner Ward as the modern father of fundraising. And if you want a recap/reminder (from our  timeline of the 20th and 21st centuries): 

Charles Sumner Ward (1858-1929) is widely credited as the founding father of modern fundraising. In 1900 he was general secretary of a YMCA branch in Michigan, where he spent much of his time fundraising using what we would recognise as standard major donor practices. However, in 1905, given the task of raising $90,000 for a new YMCA building in Washington DC, he decides to achieve this through an ‘intensive’, or ‘whirlwind’ mass appeal public fundraising appeal. He masterminds and oversees many other similar appeals for other cities, using what became known as the ‘Ward Plan’. He repeats his success in England, and throughout World War One he repeats this campaign model for the American Red Cross and United War Works. In 1920 he founds the fundraising firm Ward, Dreshman and Reinhardt in New York. 

Even when we do not have a coherent historical narrative to tell (as is arguably the case with fundraising), we nonetheless like to have a story to tell – both as fundraisers and humans. Stories are stickier and easier to remember. Perhaps that is why the Sumner Ward story has stuck.  

But as with all history, the history (or histories) of fundraising is not that simple. Is there a different story we can tell? 

An alternative historical narrative – women to the fore 

In 1893, it was estimated that there were half a million women working semi-professionally in a full-time capacity in auxiliary societies in the UK. Around 20,000 were paid officials supporting fundraising and soliciting funds. Auxiliary societies were democratic voluntary associations that worked together to finance philanthropic work (from missions to temperance movements). The auxiliary was a regional branch  of a large ‘parent’ society and members paid subscriptions to support the work and additionally raised funds to support the cause they cared about. In America, 30,000 African-American women were active in church-associated clubs similar to auxiliaries.  

Tyrone McKinley Freeman’s book looks at the role of African-American women through a fundraising lens – one of the few to do so. 

The limited scholarly exploration and the glimpses that we see gives a richer, more nuanced and more female-led approach to raising funds and running charities. This extensive involvement of women in the fundraising in the 18thand 19th centuries calls into question the standard origin myth of modern fundraising as having been driven by a few ‘great men’, such as Charles Sumner Ward and Lyman Pierce, in the early 20th century. 

The alternative historical narrative that emerges from the second fundraising timeline we have constructed as part of  Rogare’s fundraising history/historiography project  (covering the period 1500-1899) shows the much more active role of women to raise funds – as evidenced by the charity bazaar movement (see the entry for 1685) and that the first charity shop was established to sell goods made by women (see 1859). 

Collating entries for this second fundraising history timeline has revealed a much more nuanced, sophisticated and complex fundraising practice existing in the UK and the US. Many of the methods attributed to as firsts by Pierce and Sumner Ward had been used in other campaigns throughout the 18th and 19th centuries by active fundraising professionals in the UK and the US, including segmentation, mass publicity campaigns, short-focused appeals raising big gifts for capital projects, utilising mass printing of pamphlets, and mass mailing.  

As an aside from someone who has been involved in several major capital projects, the level of excitement, size of gift, and ‘noise’ that capital campaigns make may have aided Sumner Ward’s success. Capital projects create physical buildings that come with naming rights and are different to the ongoing and continuing revenue/business-as-usual funding requests. 

“By 1893, there were half a million women working in auxiliary societies in Victorian England – a huge number that bears repeating: Half a million! And 20,000 of them were working and supporting themselves as semi-professional fundraisers.” 

And as with the study of philanthropy, the same is true of fundraising – money talks! We tend to bias our attention towards the major amounts fundraised and the philanthropists who gave those amounts, and ignore the hundreds and thousands of smaller gifts from hundreds and thousands of donors who were asked to give by thousands of fundraisers. Campaigns preceding the major YMCA appeals and British Red Cross of Ward and Pierce were incredibly successful and widely supported (which does not to dismiss or diminish the success of Sumner Ward and his evolution of campaigns and establishment of practice). 

Now to return to the half a million women working in auxiliary societies in Victorian England – a huge number that bears repeating: Half a million! And 20,000 of them were working and supporting themselves as semi-professional fundraisers.  

The challenge with the history of fundraising, as Beth Breeze pointed out in her 2017 book The New Fundraisers, is that too often it is only the fruits of the labour of fundraising are known and recorded – the ultimate outcomes such as the laws changed and the votes won – but not the fundraisers. But this dismisses the work to feed, clothe, educate, and care for those in need, and the lives saved or transformed. 

There are also wider questions of what, and who, has archived this knowledge, and where we can find the evidence for it.  

Suffragettes Annie Kenney and Christabel Pankhurst. It has been argued that well-organised women-led fundraising at the start of the 19th century paved the way for the suffrage movement. 

The substantial literatures on the suffrage movement, the education reform bill, the temperance movement, or the anti-corn law movement have been studied as history and politics, informing us about our political, social and cultural past. But that same literature has not been as systematically studied for what it tells us about the history of fundraising. And that’s despite renowned British social historian Frank Prochaska arguing that the sophisticated organisation of female-led charity collections in the early 19th century paved the way for the suffrage movement.  

Fundraising is seen perhaps an adjunct, a means to an end, and not the focus of the academic or scholarly work to date on this archive. We need to use these well-archived areas to explore our fundraising history.  

But to keep and develop an archive you need to have the power and resources to store and keep records. In the USA, the so-called  Jim Crow Laws banned the right of association, restricted education and curtailed literacy for African Americans. This had a huge impact on the records that were kept about African-American clubwomen, and their role, influence and legacy has been under-explored and under-valued as a result. 

Some of these records of the clubwomen have been explored through the lens of Black studies, women’s studies, and economics, but an explicit fundraising lens or academic practise has not been established or analysed (although that is changing – do read of Tyrone McKinley Freeman’s  Madam CJ Walker’s Gospel of Giving – Black Women’s Philanthropy during Jim Crow). 

One of the reasons for creating the timelines of the histories of fundraising as a first step in Rogare’s  history of fundraising project  is to highlight these missing stories. The stories that are not documented. The stories that are not archived. Issues of intersectionality further enhance the discrepancy of what is recorded and studied.  

As with all historians gathering information, we are drawn to what is novel (the parrot taught to ask for donations in the collecting box), our own time interest, cultural understanding of philanthropy and the importance of philanthropists, and so we find what we were looking for.  

As a result, when we come to explore to the history of fundraising, we often grasp for the unusual – the fundraising ‘firsts’ – and try to weave them into a narrative arc (the fundraiser’s need for a story dominates!).   

Yet it would be as easy to create another timeline of all the under-researched and unknown aspects of fundraising – the missing stories, the lost, the hidden, the non-literate, those working in secret or fearing persecution. This of course includes the aspects of women’s active role in fundraising, which we are trying to correct. But often we lack the points of entry to that research by our own limits and biases, or what has previously been recorded and studied. As Tyrone McKinley Freeman of the Lilly Family School of Philanthropy says: “There is so much more to them and the history they give us access to if we can ask deeper and more historical questions.” 

Embrace the historical complexity 

As we publish the second part of the history of fundraising timeline, it is important to acknowledge its inadequacies and the cultural absences and silences. The short version you can see is only a snapshot, and the whole ever-growing timeline runs to hundreds of entries. It will be shared so you can see it (including the parrot example), and add your own items.  

We’ll continue to include those fundraising firsts – because they are interesting in their own right. But, as we continue exploring our histories of fundraising, let us find ways to find more points of entry to finding these stories. Let’s not shy away from the complexity of these stories in building up a picture of the histories of fundraising and let’s keep asking better and deeper questions about how fundraising has got to where it is now, what the past tells us about our present, and how it should or might develop.  

I’ve already quoted Tyrone McKinley Freeman as saying we need to ask deeper historical questions, and to direct those questions in different areas than we currently do. British historian John H Arnold (who I also quoted previously) says that “history both begins and ends with questions; which is to say it never really ends, but is a process”. 

We often want simplicity in fundraising, which is why we adopt the KISS (Keep it Simple Stupid) approach, because this simplicity often works in our day-to-day practice. We can’t be so simple in our approach to fundraising history. The answer to many historical questions we ask is likely to be “it’s complicated”. Our role as fundraising historians is to acknowledge and embrace that complexity, and to keep asking questions.  

First published November, 2023 on https://criticalfundraising.com/2023/11/07/fundraising-history-is-more-complex-than-we-think/

https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.png 0 0 admin https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.png admin2023-11-09 13:01:492024-04-09 13:02:22The history of fundraising is more complex than our simple narratives  suggest 
Page 6 of 10«‹45678›»
Tweets by meenamtj
All content © Marina Jones 2023
  • Link to X
  • Link to Instagram
  • Link to LinkedIn
Scroll to top Scroll to top Scroll to top

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

Accept settingsHide notification onlySettings

Cookie and Privacy Settings



How we use cookies

We may request cookies to be set on your device. We use cookies to let us know when you visit our websites, how you interact with us, to enrich your user experience, and to customize your relationship with our website.

Click on the different category headings to find out more. You can also change some of your preferences. Note that blocking some types of cookies may impact your experience on our websites and the services we are able to offer.

Essential Website Cookies

These cookies are strictly necessary to provide you with services available through our website and to use some of its features.

Because these cookies are strictly necessary to deliver the website, refusing them will have impact how our site functions. You always can block or delete cookies by changing your browser settings and force blocking all cookies on this website. But this will always prompt you to accept/refuse cookies when revisiting our site.

We fully respect if you want to refuse cookies but to avoid asking you again and again kindly allow us to store a cookie for that. You are free to opt out any time or opt in for other cookies to get a better experience. If you refuse cookies we will remove all set cookies in our domain.

We provide you with a list of stored cookies on your computer in our domain so you can check what we stored. Due to security reasons we are not able to show or modify cookies from other domains. You can check these in your browser security settings.

Google Analytics Cookies

These cookies collect information that is used either in aggregate form to help us understand how our website is being used or how effective our marketing campaigns are, or to help us customize our website and application for you in order to enhance your experience.

If you do not want that we track your visit to our site you can disable tracking in your browser here:

Other external services

We also use different external services like Google Webfonts, Google Maps, and external Video providers. Since these providers may collect personal data like your IP address we allow you to block them here. Please be aware that this might heavily reduce the functionality and appearance of our site. Changes will take effect once you reload the page.

Google Webfont Settings:

Google Map Settings:

Google reCaptcha Settings:

Vimeo and Youtube video embeds:

Other cookies

The following cookies are also needed - You can choose if you want to allow them:

Privacy Policy

You can read about our cookies and privacy settings in detail on our Privacy Policy Page.

Privacy Policy
Accept settingsHide notification only