• Link to X
  • Link to Instagram
  • Link to LinkedIn
Marina Jones
  • My Thoughts
  • What I’m Reading
  • About Me
  • Contact Me
  • Home Page
  • Click to open the search input field Click to open the search input field Search
  • Menu Menu

Tag Archive for: silly stuff

Potato, potato – let’s call the whole thing off

August 7, 2026/in Thoughts/by admin

(Does anyone actually say po-tat-toe?! And not Poh-tay-to)

Are you turning your cause into a potato?

Reading ‘Inside the Nudge Unit’ by David Halpern and how small nudges can make a big difference in everything from speeding, to tax collection and organ donation I was really struck by this story about potatoes. Stay with me…

It all comes down to a Prussian king and a humble root vegetable and leads us to some great lessons on persuasion, nudging and how you can apply that to your fundraising.

So first a Prussian king and a potato

Frederick the Great, eighteenth century Prussian king, wanted his people to grow and eat potatoes. He ordered Kartoffelbefehl – edicts ordering that potatoes were planted and grown. They were nutritious, resilient and could help prevent famine. But there was a problem. People didn’t trust potatoes. They were seen as strange, foreign and even dangerous. So they wouldn’t eat them. Rationally, they answered a need but emotionally they were rejected.

In an infamous (possibly apocryphal) example of the application of decision science and nudging Frederick the Great changed the the whole narrative

Instead of leaning in hard to the rational approach and doing a public education campaign on the nutritional facts about potato or agricultural yield (a classic System 2 approach), he made potatoes appear scarce, royal and desirable. He planted royal potato fields and had them guarded. Not heavily guarded – in fact the guards were encouraged to be lax in their guarding duties. He wanted the guard to signal value to the people – to show that the potatoes were worth guarding na desirable.

What happened?

People began to steal the potatoes.

The same people that had rejected them now wanted them. Why? Because their meaning had changed. Potatoes were no longer “suspicious roots”. They were something the king valued. They were guarded. They became worth stealing.

Behavioural science helps us understand why this worked.

First, scarcity. We place higher value on things that appear limited or restricted. If something is everywhere and freely available, our brains discount it. If it is rare or protected, our brains assign it value and it becomes increasingly attractive.

Second, authority messengers. If the king values something, it must be worth valuing. The messenger who communicates with us influences how we hear the message. In eighteenth century Prussia, the king was a powerful messenger – we can use the authority of the messenger to short circuit whether we ought to listen.

Third, reactance – when something feels restricted or forbidden, we want it more.

“Picture reactance  as something that turns your lovely reader into a wilful teenager. One with the tendency to do the exact opposite of what you ask them to do” 

– Lisa Sergeant

The guards guarding (but not working too hard at it) created just enough friction to trigger desire without making access impossible.

Fourth, framing. The frame we put around an idea changes how we think about it. We believe the story that we tell ourselves. The potato itself did not change. The story around it did. And that story changed behaviour.

Why should we as fundraisers care about it?

Because this is fundraising.

Too often, we present our causes like the early potato – rational, worthy, full of facts and benefits. We explain reach, impact, efficiency. We assume that if people understand, they will act.

But like the Prussian farmers, our supporters are not making decisions purely on information. They are responding to emotion and to cues about value, meaning and desirability.

The perception of the potato changed – not the potato itself.

What can fundraisers learn from the potato?

1 Make Value visible

If everything is available to everyone, it can feel less valuable. Limited opportunities, exclusive access or matched funding windows can increase perceived importance and urgency.

2. Use signals of importance
Leadership gifts, named supporters, or visible champions act like the “royal guard”. They signal that something matters and is worth attention.

3. Frame, don’t just inform
The way you present an opportunity matters as much as the opportunity itself. Story, context and symbolism shape behaviour more than raw data.

4. Lean into curiosity
People are drawn to what feels slightly out of reach. A sense of discovery or insider access can be more motivating than full transparency upfront.

5. Test, don’t assume
What feels logical (telling people potatoes are good for them) may not work. What feels counterintuitive (guarding them) might. The only way to know is to test.

Like many behavioural science insights, the lesson is both simple but powerful.

We think we make decisions based on what something is.

In reality, we make decisions based on what it means.

And sometimes, all it takes to change behaviour is not to change the thing itself – but to change the story we tell about it.

https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2026/08/Picture-1.jpg 462 451 admin https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.png admin2026-08-07 08:07:312026-08-07 08:07:31Potato, potato – let’s call the whole thing off

What should a fundraiser dress up for on World Book Day?

March 2, 2026/in What I'm Reading/by admin

Here is an AI version of me dressed as Elizabeth Zott from Lessons in Chemistry 

The challenge for World Book Day is often finding a character from a book, not a TV programme or film (although this version of looks rather more like Brie Larson in the tv show, that how I pictured her in the book.)

Elizabeth Zott in the book is a scientist who has to battle to get, and keep, academic grants, and fit into the priorities of funders. All the time being undermined by her boss who misleads the philanthropist supporting her work that she is a man and diverting funds from their proper use.  

‘A fairy godmother is just another word for a philanthropist. A rich person who gives money to causes’

Harriet tells Zott’s daughter Mad

Zott’s struggles remind me of a real life scientist, Professor Sarah Gilbert, who devised the Oxford Astra Zeneca Covid19 vaccination who said:

“Actually, raising funds had been my main activity for years… I trained for years to become really good at ‘doing science! .. but… what I actually spend my time doing these days is, mostly, bringing in the money. This [system] can be counterproductive for the cause of scientific research itself… ” 

‘Vaxxers’ by Prof Sarah Gilbert and Dr Cath Green

The other reason I choose Elizabeth Zott is because of her scientific approach – when applying the principles of decision science to fundraising is important to be rigour and scientific – see here for more https://marinajones.uk/chemistry/

So in what other stories do we see fundraisers that we could dress up as – or be inspired by?

  • So in the words of Tom Lehrer ‘drag out the Dickens’, Charles Dickens novels in Victorian London often feature fundraising activities.
    • A Christmas Carol starts with fundraisers collecting for the poor who are dismissed by Scrooge (and told the poor should die and decrease the surplus population 
    • Mrs Jellaby in Bleak House so concerned for the far away Borrioboola-Gha and assuming raising funds that she cannot look after her own family or needs

For either of these a Victorian bonnet outfit could work for World Book Day.

  • An easy possibly generic costume would be a Girl Scout and girl scouts raising funds via cookie sales could be used.
  • For parents, or those that remember learning to read with them, the Biff and Chip Oxford Reading Tree books could offer the answer – raising funds features in several books

Or do we go with a smart business look and go as Sarah Jane in Janice Hallet’s The Appeal mystery where she uses her professional fundraising skills to coordinate an Appeal for Poppy?

You are what you consume  

Cultivation theory tells us our perception of the world around us is learnt from the culture we consume which we unconsciously mimic and how tropes and exposure to these story impacts how we may think about fundraising. The challenge when exploring fundraising and fundraisers through fiction is sometimes our experience of positive role models can be limiting, sometimes the reputational laundering, nefarious billionaire hiding a dirty secret through philanthropic acts dominates the literary tropes. Although, sometimes perhaps deeper truths are revealed about our attitudes to raising money or money itself. 

So we may quickly run out of positive and easily recognisable or achievable costumes. And move to some more real world types that expose different facets of fundraising and insights into the profession but not always in the best light. 

Some less salubrious fundraisers in fiction

Jack Schmidt, Arts Administrator– Jack turns into an Arts Administrator (fundraising consultant) when private detective work dries up because ‘What your arts organizations need is a guy who can ask people for large amounts without blushing and twisting his hankies’.

The short story begins with this line  

‘It was one of those sweltering days toward the end of the fiscal year when Minneapolis smells of melting asphalt and foundation money is as tight as a rusted nut’  

and includes lines like 

‘Now anyone who can spell ‘innovative’ can apply for a grant … but that doesn’t mean that the bozo who reads the application is necessarily going to burst into tears and run right down to Western Union’ 

and goes on to extol the added value of the consultant writing the application (he is a consultant after all) and

‘Your fat cats will millions to build an arts center, but nobody wants to donate to pay the light bill because you can’t put a plaque on it. They’ll pay for Chippewa junk sculpture but who wants to endow janitors’

In The Ask by Sam Lypsite a major gifts fundraiser at “Mediocre University” gets fired, but is reinstated in the role to make an ask from a rich friend from college. (‘Our job was to grovel for more money’ offering a rather cynical and depressing outlook on fundraising from protagonist Milo on naming rights, fundraising practice and ‘asks’)

In Jacqueline Wilson’s Hetty Feather series of books set in the Foundling Hospital the reliance on fundraised income is apparent – using the foundlings to demonstrate impact, having visitors watch them at Sunday church services and dinners and various fundraising events including charity concerts, fairs and events – living our the show don’t tell approach.

It is frequently through events that we see more glimpses of fundraisers and fundraising in stories. 

  • In Emily Henry’s Book Lovers a community comes together and donating time and talents to fundraiser together and save the store (this is a familiar trope for the Hallmark type stories)
  • Margaret Mitchell’s Gone With the Wind includes the Charity Bazaar dance where they are raising funds and Rhett bids to dance with widow Scarlett and Mellie and Scarlett donate their wedding rings to raise funds. 
  • In Jenny Jackson – Pineapple Street at fundraising gala we see ‘The hope, of course, was that he would be so moved by the evening’s proceedings that he would leave a pledge in a small envelope set under his dinner plate’

The psychology of when to making the ask can be seen A Changed Man by Francine Prose –  when the key moment is described as 

“monitoring his tiny tics has turned out to be excellent training, useful now in her work as she watched a donor’s face for the perfect moment to raise the subject of giving.”

Although a book that describes fundraising as ‘physic blackmail’ and working a room at a gala dinner as balancing

‘nerdy sincerity…reassuring to potential big ticket donors’ and knowing everyone ‘kiss kiss, chat chat, say a few words, spin off … it’s her job’ 

might not be the best way to inspire us to take pride in the profession! 

So lets return to a more positive example in Elizabeth Zott blending expertise in your field with navigating the world of securing the grants to make your work happen.

https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.png 0 0 admin https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.png admin2026-03-02 13:04:442026-03-02 13:04:51What should a fundraiser dress up for on World Book Day?

Legacy fundraisers cultural list …

September 9, 2024/in What I'm Reading/by admin

Where do we see legacies in literature, poetry, plays, opera and music?

Some fun examples and lessons to be learned from them.

A fun cultural list for legacy fundraisers …

Music

  1. Anti Heroine – Taylor Swift

The rise of charitable legacies to spite relations or family is often cited and results in contested wills – in the song ‘Anti Heroine’ Taylor Swift leaves the money to the cat sanctuary and her family are surprised as they wanted to get their hands on the cash. During the funeral scene the will is read saying:

‘The beach house will be converted into a cat sanctuary for the aforementioned’

If pledgers speak to their family about their wishes before they die it can avoid these contested wills.

Full video here https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b1kbLwvqugk

.

2. Gianni Schicchi

Scheming relatives in Puccini’s Gianni Schicchi when hearing of the charitable intention of their dying relation plot to rewrite his will to their advantage – but they still want to appear charitable so include a small bequest to the monastery.

.

And in literature – where a bequest is central to the plot

3. A Month in the Country by J L Carr

Tom Birkin’s employment is based on a legacy bequest with conditions. The church’s Fabric Fund won’t get the £1,000 legacy until the deceased wishes are honoured to uncover the hidden painting (with £25 set aside for it)

4. The Warden

The Warden (could be subtitled ‘When charitable legacies go wrong’) by Anthony Trollope centres around whether Hiram’s will and charitable legacy to create a hospital for 12 wool carders of Barchester. This has been correctly enacted and the good management of the land affords the warden a higher income and greater benefits to those living there – as times have changed and they do not follow the strict conditions of the will.

John Bold a reformer launches a campaign in the press to protest how the will has been enacted. Mr Harding, at the advice of the archdeacon stands his ground. Trollope is concerned with contemporary scandals and suspicions ‘that the grasping priests of the Church of England are gorged with wealth which the charity of former times has left for the solace of the aged, or the education of the young’

The arguments are played out in the popular press, pamphlets and courts. Dr Pessimist Anticant (pause for a moment to admire the name) publishes a pamphlet on ‘Modern Charity’ contrasting the legator’s generousity with the warden’s current ‘avarice’ And reformer Mr Popular Sentiment (a fictional Charles Dickens) has written a novel about the whole almshouse system and scandal – Trollope highlights the power of fiction to inform and influence us saying ‘monthly novels convince, when learned quartos fail to do so“.

5. The Seven Husband of Evelyn Hugo

It is rare for a book to begin with a charitable bequest – but that is just what Taylor Jenkins Reid’s ‘The Seven Husbands of Evelyn Hugo’ does – her in death giving reflect her lifetime giving. It shows that as well as money items can be donated and sold to benefit the charity.

Do you offer your supporters the chance to donate items or just money?

.

7. The Great Believers

This novel takes place during the AIDS crisis and the story centres on a character who is navigating a substantial art donation for a university gallery.

“What we’re hoping for is a flat out bequest. She hasn’t given to the annual fund since 1970, and those were small gifts… People like that tend to underestimate how much they have”

This highlights a truth often seen in legacy fundraising that your prospects may be asset rich but cash poor – but incredibly loyal. Just because someone hasn’t been coming or giving a lot doesn’t mean that you are not important.

The fundraiser protects the wishes of the legator over the gallery’s more commercial plans for the space. It is important that legators have trust that their legacy wishes will be honoured and enacted.

Poetry

6. Bristol and Clifton – John Betjeman

And this poem by John Betjeman ‘Bristol and Clifton’ talks of in memory given for the his late wife. The poem also talks of brass donor plaques and congregational collections.

Donors who give in memory are more likely to include gifts in their will to support the cause so it is important to engage with the whole family.

Short stories and comics

8. Jack Schmidt Arts Administrator

‘It was one of those sweltering days toward the end of the fiscal year when Minneapolis smells of melting asphalt and foundation money is as tight as a rusted nut’

How’s this for a (philanthropic) first line?

Jack turns into an Arts Administrator (fundraising consultant) when private detective work dries up because ‘What your arts organizations need is a guy who can ask people for large amounts without blushing and twisting his hankies’

He secures a range of grants for various arts causes …but struggles to get core costs funded (plus ca change)

Your fat cats will millions to build an arts center, but nobody wants to donate to pay the light bill because you can’t put a plaque on it. They’ll pay for Chippewa junk sculpture but who wants to endow janitors“

He even makes a legacy pitch – although the dogs that the donor adores look at him suspiciously …

9. Batman

Batman’s mission to fight crime and injustice comes from a desire to honour the legacy of his parents. Sometimes in life gifts reflect others who have been influential in our lives.

So look out for legacy giving in all forms of literature … and remember

  • Encourage your supporters to talk to their family about their wishes
  • In memory givers make great potential legators
  • In life giving and connections drive legacy pledgers
  • Think about the various ways people can
  • Encourage legacy pledgers to speak to a legal professional to ensure that the conditions of the will can be enacted correctly.
https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/09/FfnWG0gWQAgRzyd.jpef_.jpeg 383 680 admin https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.png admin2024-09-09 21:31:092024-09-09 21:31:10Legacy fundraisers cultural list …

Make it easy pee-sy; what can fundraisers learn from WC design

July 9, 2024/in Thoughts/by admin

There are thousands of tiny design choices that help make our interactions easier and simpler as we move around the world. This design architecture makes it easier for our brains to process what is asked of us.

We see it on trains, planes and on public transport.

And on restaurant menus – and you can use these to help with your fundraising here and here.

But, we also see it in bathrooms – so what do we see and why does it work.

So here are some ways that behavioural nudges in bathroom design could be used to add nudges to your fundraising

1. Make it easy – colour coding & availability

These WCs at Kings Cross station have lights above the stalls – green for free and red for occupied (this lighting scheme is also used in car parks).

Green in travel means go, and red says stop (also danger, anger, love and lust). Red traditionally means warning, and gets our attention – our primitive brains have evolved to respond quicker to red, and this quicker processing answers the evolutionary imperative and keeps us safe and away from danger.

So, if colours have this powerful and innate reaction in our brains, how can we use them to help our fundraising? To help guide our donors and to increase the fluency of a donor journey?

And, what colour should your donation buttons be?

  • Red for attention and urgency? If we can process it faster and know it grabs attention? Does red prime people to stop? Or increase the sense of urgency and demand action?
  • Or green for go?
  • Or a contrasting colour to your brand colour to stand out in a different way?

(I have not seen any experiments or data to show what works for one charity – we need to test the most impactful colours with our donor base and with specific appeals)

2. Why do banana skin safety cones increase safety?

We have a pre-existing knowledge that bananas are slippery.

This knowledge has been around since 1800s (or as long as people have eaten bananas and dropped them onto a hard surface). In the 1800s bananas were popular in New York but poor sanitation meant rotted on the streets and became slippery and the comedy gag developed. This well known trope is recognised by children and adults and in different cultures.

So scientists applied this knowledge to the safety cone – testing various shaped warning signs to warn people.

So banana shaped safety warning codes attract our attention because they are a novelty shape and colour and it links to our pre-existing knowledge that bananas as are slippery. The tests demonstrated that a banana shaped warning code reduced incidents and accidents.

  • How can we use our supporters pre existing knowledge of tropes or shapes (or fruit) to inform behaviour?

3. Feedback loop

We appreciate immediate feedback that demonstrates the instant impact of our actions and choices – pressing a button gives us a reward – an ego boost – for contributing our opinion. This feedback about the cleanliness of the toilets gives us positive way to feedback. These buttons also enhance our agency by adding to our illusion of being in control .  – it also links into the Ikea effect that we value something more if we have been involved in the construction of it. Offering feedback is a way of engaging and demonstrating our connection.

  • How can we ask for feedback from our supporters on the impact they make? That gives them an ego boost for participating, allowing us to quickly adjust our behaviour.

It can be something as simple as seeing the line rise on the fundraising thermometer – online, or a more old fashioned physical one likes these examples

4. To pee or not to pee

An enormous amount of scientific time and effort has been spent trying to get men to reduce spillage when using urinals. A few notable examples:

Aim at the goal
Aim at the fly

The fly example (right) at Schiphol airport reduced spillage by 80% and reduced cleaning costs by 8% – showing the power and efficacy of these fun but simple nudges.

And a drunk driving one…testing if you can ‘drive’ straight.

  • How could you apply this to your fundraising? And make a simple process more fun and engaging? More of a rewarding game?

5. Clear expectations

Public spaces are increasingly using visual signage – these from the People’s Museum in Manchester show you want to expect in the different WCs. We process images faster than words so this speed up cognitive processing and makes it easier for our brains to know what behaviours are expected.

  • How can you use visual signage and infographics to help donors process the information that you want them to know and understand what action you want them to take?

6. Catch people where they are

The mere exposure effect says that the more we are exposed to a message, the faster and easier it is for our neurons to process. The more we see the message, the faster we get at processing and understanding it.

How can you prime them to think about making a donation when they are in the WC?

I am a big fan of posters on the back of toilet doors. Repeating messages that they have seen in other campaigns can nudge towards the desired behaviour. The Bluecoat example below shows someone giving and invites you to make a gift – when you see the donation box in the foyer you have been primed to put money in it.

Or use the doors as a whole advert like these bold ones at Kew Gardens.

7. Donor recognition can go anywhere – even bathrooms!

Harvard graduate William Falk wanted to fund a fellowship in public interest law to honour his father but when it came to naming rights he joked with the dean “The only thing I’ve ever been able to name with a name like ‘Falik’ is a restroom.” (pronounced ‘phallic’) and so his gift is recognised there.

After hearing that philanthropist Heidi Roizen was turned down by Stanford University with her offer of a gift to name a bathroom, Brad Feldman offered to name a bathroom at MIT but they also deemed it ‘inappropriate’. His local college in Boulder heard about it and invited him to make a gift to name a bathroom there and so he did. They received a donation of $25,000 and his donor credit includes this quote up in the bathroom

The best ideas often come at inconvenient times — don’t ever close your mind to them.

This has inspired him in a philanthropic bathroom donating career – he now has four bathrooms – each with a $25,000 gift his decided value of a bathroom naming right!

Another donor at the University of Pennsylvania has this quote up to recognise his gift

“The relief you are now experiencing is made possible by a gift from Michael Zinman”

Naming rights is not just a solo activity – it can be a fun way to celebrate your friendship – these two urinals are next to each other – Adam gifted one to his friend David, and David reciprocated and named one for Adam.


Whilst these all celebrate the joys of naming rights – naming a toilet block after a legal wrangle and a small donation a charity named a toilet block after an MP.

Donor credits really can go anywhere.

So what can we learn from WC design and behavioural nudges

  • Make it easy – make it visually easy to process what you want the donor to use
  • Colour code it – use familiar shapes and colours to guide the donor journey
  • Find ways to provide a feedback loop and give them a hit of dopamine (one of the happy chemicals)
  • Show the impact of their donation on the total target or the project
  • Make the process fun and engaging
  • Use images – they are easier for our process than just words
  • Repeat your message – repeatedly expose donors to your messages
  • Donor crediting can go anywhere and for the right donor might be the right project

Read more about

Nudges on trains, planes and on public transport.

And on restaurant menus – and you can use these to help with your fundraising here and here

https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/07/Designer.png 1024 1024 admin https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.png admin2024-07-09 20:47:092024-08-02 12:10:18Make it easy pee-sy; what can fundraisers learn from WC design

Take Back Your Mink! Fun fundraising lessons from ‘Guys & Dolls’

June 28, 2024/in Thoughts/by admin

Inspired by a blog a few years ago looking at some fun fundraising ideas from My Fair Lady with Dominic Haddock & having enjoyed the Bridge Theatre’s Guys & Dolls here are a few fun and silly ways this classic musical could inspire your fundraising …

.

1. Where to host the crap game

“The Biltmore garage wants a grand 
But we ain’t got a grand on hand.“

The search for where to hold your events can be problematic – as you return to the same venues year after year with the same issues.

What is their eventual solution? Hosting the crap game in the mission whilst Sky takes Sister Sarah to Havana and eventually decamping to the sewers – demonstrating the need for creative solutions to repeated problems that we have (just maybe not in a sewer!)

2. Red carnations to get into the crap game

When they do decide on where to host the game, they need a signal to know who is coming to the game. The gamblers all wear red carnations and they tell Lt Branigan it is for Nathan’s Bachelor party. Identity, and signalling identity, can be really important to supporters – whether that is through the name that you give them as a group or circle of supporters, or provide other ways for them to identify themselves to other supporters or signal their status – from enamel pin badges, ties, tote bags to names on donor walls.

3. Take Back Your Mink

“Take Back your pearls, what made you think I was one of those girls…

Take Back the Hat, the shoes and the gown,

I may be down but I’m not as flat as all that.

But when I think about what you want in exchange…”

There seem to be three potential lessons here for the fundraiser … all about the importance of saying no and walking away from bad or demanding relationships.

  • The importance of saying no when funding expectations are too much. We have all been there when a gift is being discussed and the demands of the donors become greater and greater. No matter how far you have got in the relationship when the expectations are out of balance you need to remain true to your mission, values and the integrity of the work and walk away and refuse to cooperate is sometimes the best thing you can do
  • This could equally apply to the donor, and how they might experience the fundraising courtship process of soliciting a major gift and the expectations that the charity might have on the donor in terms of financial commitment, and other expectations (opening address books, networks or time), and again the need to step away from that relationship
  • More problematically it could apply to the power imbalance between a major donor and an individual fundraiser and inappropriate propositions made in order to secure a gift, again a time to remove yourself from the situation.

The song always end with the dancers rushing back on stage and retrieving the gown, mink, gloves, pearls etc., and challenging the audience

“Well, wouldn’t you?”

Which rather depressingly might speak to the fact that charities sometimes still accept the money despite the unreasonable the demands, or ethics of a donor. Do charities sometimes accept the money because they need it even when they have misgivings about the relationship?

And an added extra

My parents saw a production of Guys and Dolls years ago, and still have a garter thrown into the audience during this scene. Souvenirs are really important for supporters to remember those key experiences – in arts charities that can be programmes, ticket stubs but for super engaged fans they can be bit of the curtain or carpet. One donor I knew had a drawer full of these souvenirs – they funded a lots of arts education so it included mini sets created with match boxes and blood stained handkerchiefs from prop makers workshops. These tangible reminders of support help create memories, and remind us of those powerful experiences.

4. “Sit Down You’re Rocking the Boat“

A negative view means this might mean that charities stick to their knitting in the infamous words of the former MP for civil society.

But I prefer to think of this as as – always have an encore built in.

‘Sit Down You’re Rocking the Boat’ is scheduled to be the showstopper moment in the show, and has several pre rehearsed encores built into the show.

How can you build an encore into your supporter care and experience?

5. “When you see a guy reach for stars in the sky 
You can bet that he’s doing it for some doll.
”

The song speaks of guys doing out of character things to impress the women in their life – a phenomena called the peacock’s tail.

In evolutionary terms, the peacock’s tail is costly signalling and is there for sexual selection – peahens have evolved to show a preference for mates with brighter feathers and bigger tails. The tail serves to advertise the health and status of the peacock. In survival terms it makes the peacock more attractive to others – but this comes at a cost – the tail is cumbersome and would slow a peacock down if under attack. It is a calculated cost risk to advertise so blatantly. So peacocks have evolved to have brighter feathers and bigger tails.

Being philanthropic or altruistic is a way in which humans can do costly signalling.

When performing in front of a female audience, in a lab setting, men have been shown to be more philanthropic and demonstrate their kindness and altruism (in lab experiments, this behaviour was not seen in females). Men’s contributions doubled when they rated the female observers as more attractive.

This behaviour is not just seen in a lab but in real life – people can be more generous in public – at a charity auction – with a ballroom full of people watching – this is known as competitive altruism – and can be used as a powerful way to enhance reputation, signal your suitability to be a caring partner and good gene quality

Researchers (Iredale & Van Vogt, 2009) have posited that the ‘altruism is sexy’ then charities could use that in communications to promote more public prosocial behaviour.

6. “Luck be a lady tonight“

Despite the best strategy, plans, introductions and aspirations there is always an element of rolling the dice and luck in fundraising.

7. “This is not a charity contribution, this is a business transaction”

Says Sky Masterson giving his marker to Sister Sarah Brown for two dozen genuine sinner – we all think about gifts in different ways – sometimes the gift is purely altruistic, sometimes fulfilling an obligation, sometimes business – to gain access, power or status. It is important to know how your donor might be thinking about their gift.

8. And the power of reinvention

The Bridge Theatre version of the show, directed by Nicholas Hynter, has been running for over a year. It stages the musical, traditionally done in a Proscenium Arch (picture frame) theatre in a new immersive setting. The audience are on all four sides and you can buy tickets to stand, and with a standing ticket you get moved around an ever moving set with platforms rising and falling as you are guided into the right spaces by an ever dedicated team of front of house staff. At the end there is a party, with members of the cast and audience members dancing together.

To take a well known stage musical from the 1950s musical and keep its essence but reinvent for a new space – how can your fundraising learn from that?

Caveat – these are deliberately fun and slightly trivial examples –  and it is not to downplay the problematic nature of a period pieces of theatre with issues of gambling addiction, alcohol abuse amongst many others.

https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/06/IMG_7136-scaled.jpg 1920 2560 admin https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.png admin2024-06-28 08:06:472024-06-28 08:06:47Take Back Your Mink! Fun fundraising lessons from ‘Guys & Dolls’

Gangster style fundraising

June 2, 2024/in What I'm Reading/by admin

Before MrBeast and stunt philanthropy there was another stunt philanthropist on the scene – a gang of them in fact. Ferguson’s Gang – from the 1920s to the 1950s they fundraised for the National Trust.

But they didn’t just post a cheque with a donation. They wanted to make a splash with their donations so they always involved a stunt, often masked like gangsters, and helped generate publicity, and further funds.

This was reported in The Guardian and I read the book detailing their activities, activism with more autobiographical details about the gang members – you can read for yourself.

Introduction to Ferguson’s Gang

In 1927, on a picnic the idea for the gang was formed to protect the natural world and historic houses from the ever expanding urbanisation and sprawl of London. They wanted to raise money to preserve the countryside and save beauty spots – England for them was Stonehenge not Whitehall.

The idea was formed by a group of women who decided that they would do this as a gang with gangster names – the gang names were:

  • Bill Stickers
  • Kate O’Brien The Nark
  • Red Biddy
  • Sister Agatha
  • Bludy Beershop

In total over their career, Ferguson’s Gang donated over £5,000 to the National Trust and preserved six properties including the Old Mill, Shalford, Trevescan Cliffs Sennon and Priory Cottages Stevenson.

So a little more about their approach and what is useful from a fundraising point of view.

Stunt philanthropy

Ferguson’s Gang recorded each donation as a ‘drop’ adopting the gangster argot.

Their first drop was in 1932. They had raised £100 but rather than a cheque or a banknote they used half crowns – half crowns were 1/8th of a British pound so this would be 800 coins. They put these coins in a gangster style swag bag.

So the first donation…

They arrived in a taxi, having stopped en route at luxury department store Harrods to purchase masks to hide their identity, rang the doorbell of the National Trust’s headquarters and handed over Ferguson’s Gang business card and were taken to see the Secretary of the National Trust. They were admitted and made their gift.

The novelty of the approach got them press coverage who reported ‘Some benevolent “gangsters” masked lady weighed down with swag”and encouraged others to make donations.

“Anonymity is a quality not unknown among donors of gifts to the National Trust, but rarely is generosity concealed by a disguise so mysterious that assumed by the benefactors … known as ‘Ferguson’s Gang’. … a masked lady, recently astonished officials of the Trust … Without lifting her mask she gave £100 in silver to the secretary”

The Times

Each ‘drop’ (except one) was reported in the paper.

The second drop involved Erb the Smasher (the brother of Bill Stickers) in a maskdelivering two £100 notes.

“Gangsters in England are not common but this is a type of gangster who ought to be encouraged”

Good Housekeeping

Sometimes however there stunts were a little risky and had the potential to go wrong. At the National Trust annual dinner in 1936 they made a drop – this time a £100 note was wrapped in a cigar and given to Lord Zealand of the National Trust. They then spent the evening in fear that he would light the cigar and destroy the gift! But luckily he realised in time.

The National Trust came to expect the drama of each drop and reported themselves disappointed when a Christmas Eve donation arrived in a sweet tin without the theatrics. Their acknowledgement to the Gang reports that ‘we didn’t think it up to standard.’

Their 1939 July drop at the National Trust’s AGM was perhaps their boldest.

With the threat of war and IRA activity in London, three masked figures burst into the meeting and presented the assembled National Trust leadership with what they feared was a bomb. It then became almost like a game of pass the parcel – it was handed to James Lee Milne, who passed it o Donald Macleod Matheson to Lord Zetland. Closer examination revealed that it was not a bomb but a large metal pineapple with the note

“Open this fruit and you will find a kernel greatly to your mind”

Inside was £100 note

This was widely reported in The Daily Telegraph as a ‘Benevolent Bomb.’

Aside – what would happen if Ferguson’s Gang made at a drop at your charity today?

A masked bandit arrives in reception with a business card and a swag bag, what would the response be?

  • sorry, we don’t take cash
  • sorry we don’t know the source of this wealth and need to go through due diligence processes
  • sorry we find the violent connotations of criminal gangs problematic and not aligned with our values
  • or would it become a viral TikTok sensation?

Power of cash

The ‘drops’ were always made using cash which is interesting to note.

With debates now on giving cash or contactless – physical money and for the gang coins were important. There is something more tangible about physical money – we can hold it, feel its weight and when we make a donation hear the sound it makes. When natural disasters happen, there is often a desire to give stuff not cash as we want to do something concrete and meaningful – you can read more about this here. When the ask is for cash there is something more meaningful and personal about cash rather than tapping a device. Cash can also be used to fund treats rather than traceable necessities which you can read more about here.

Before #FirstFiver there was another royal money fundraiser

#FirstFiver was set up in 2016 when the new banknotes were issued and it raised over £12 million when it was suggested by John Thompson that you donate your first fiver to charity.

Ferguson’s Gang had a novel way of raising some of their funds.

All coins they received with Queen Victorias head on had to go into the collection for their work. Queen Victoria had been dead for over twenty five years when they started collecting but evidently there were enough coins still in circulation to make this a good way of fundraising, but novel enough that it was not all the coins in their purse!

Let's hope round two of #FirstFiver is even more successful.

Spread the joy of giving by donating your first King Charles III £5 note from 5th June onwards 🙂@CIOFtweets @caf @NCVO @ACEVO #CharityTuesday https://t.co/bEBUJajslS pic.twitter.com/HQDj1Kad2s

— John Thompson, aka Johnny Five (@JTCHANGINGBIZ) May 28, 2024
  • In June 2024, the new Charles III banknotes are due out in the UK, who will you donate your #FirstFiver to?

Admin is important

Although an anarchic gang with bohemian tendencies administration was still important.

Ferguson’s Gang bought a stamp at stationers WHSmith with Ferguson’s signature to stamp on documents.

And at each ‘drop’ at the National Trust despite the clandestine nature of their operation they always waited for a receipt for the gift.

  • Even gangsters need receipts.

Identity – join the gang

One of the ways they raised their charitable funds was through subscription. When you joined as a subscribing member of the gang you got to choose your own gang name. This is a great way to show connection with the cause and identify as a supporter. Membership tier levels often have names themed to the charity.

  • How can you reinforce your supporters’ connection to your charity by giving them a linked name and identity?

Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery

In 1938 a copy cat gang called Black Atropine Sisters started who did some similar stunt philanthropy after The Daily Mail falsely reported that the gang has disbanded. It was reported in the paper that jealously of the new Sisters gang, reawakened the gang’s activities. The Black Atropine Sisters eventually joined up with Ferguson’s Gang on some stunts.

  • It can be great to learn from the best and adapt ideas from what you see working for other charities. But a word of warning, just because something works for one charity or gang, doesn’t necessarily mean it can work for you. You need to test what works for your donors.

How you can anonymously appear on the radio?

Ferguson’s Gang was invited to do the BBC Radio 4 charity appeal in 1935 for the National Trust.

How could they do that and retain their anonymity?

Bill Stickers’ brother, Erb the Smasher was roped in to do it on condition that the anonymity of the gang could be protected. So he delivered the message wearing a mask. He directly appealed for support for members (equating the membership fee to the same fee for a radio licence fee) and donations.

At this time, the National Trust was 40 years old with only 5,000 subscribers. The radio appeal resulted in a 20% increase in membership getting 300 new Associate Members at 2/6 and 600 members at 10/ a year. The largest donation was £100 and the smallest was 5d and £900 was raised.

(It also raises the question about those raising money on your behalf. Ferguson’s Gang were independent of the National Trust and could support or generate publicity and funds for any cause they chose to. Their unorthodox tactics generated a great deal of positive press coverage and added to support of the National Trust. The National Trust choosing them to front this appeal shows how connected they were. But there can be risks associated with unconnected people raising funds that could damage reputation (if a stunt had gone wrong….))

So how could you be more ‘benevolent gangster’ in your fundraising approach?

References

National Trust page on the gang

Ferguson’s Gang book

National Trust podcast on the Gang

https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/mask2.jpeg 289 679 admin https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.png admin2024-06-02 13:33:022024-06-02 13:33:03Gangster style fundraising

Winkle Up!

March 26, 2024/0 Comments/in Thoughts/by admin

In the last few years gamification has been highlighted as a way to increase engagement with supporters – making charitable engagement more fun, and driving loyalty and community.

But it is not new in fundraising.

Competition and gaming elements can be seen in cathedral building in the thirteenth century – with areas of the city competing against each other to raise the most money (Pavia Gate vs Porta Nuevo Gate https://marinajones.uk/butter/).

But have you ever been asked to ‘winkle up’?

This is a particular request made by members of the Winkle Club in Hastings

Founded in the Prince Albert pub in Hastings in 1900 by local fisherman wanting to do something for poor local families and provide a special Christmas feast.

Each member is given a winkle shell (an edible sea snail – with snail removed and filled with wax) which must be produced if challenged to ‘winkle-up’ by a fellow member. If they cannot produce their winkle they are fined (originally 1 penny but now £1). The challenger must report the winkle up challenge before the week is out or pay a double fine!

They have become a local institution, in 1908

A hundred hungry men were served with dinner in the Harbour Shed, decorated with bunting, on Tuesday (31 Dec), while an estimated 750 children were given a good square meal dinner on Wednesday”.

Hastings Mail
Members of the Winkle Club preparing for the annual Christmas party 1948

Pubs seem to be a fruitful place for the founding of charities as Howard Lake recently commented.

Additional fines and penalties were imposed, but all for fun, including

  • It is frequently easy to induce a member to ‘go over and Winkle Up old so-and-so there in the corner for a lark’, only to find that old-so-and-so is not a member. Another fine. All’s fair in Winkling-up and it all goes to charity

The Club’s rule also cite:

  • A favourite trick is for one member to say to another: “Put your winkle on the table for a moment; I should like to compare it with mine for colour” – or size or any other excuse. If the other fellow in a thoughtless moment puts his winkle down, he at once becomes liable for a fine. Moreover, no member may ever have two winkles in his possession. Another artful dodge is casually to invite a member to pick up and examine a second winkle with some appropriate remark – “Have you ever seen one like that?” or something of the sort. If he unthinkingly takes it, he is at once in trouble and a fine is duly levied“

The Winkle King

In the 1960s, Slogger Hoad was the Winkle King of Hastings and had special suit made out of 9,626 winkles which took six months to make (and can be seen at the Hastings Fisherman Museum)

Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery

The Winkle Club originally got the idea from the Hasting Acorn Club. This Club formed in the Royal Oak pub and has an acorn as their symbol, but the fisherman of the Prince Albert wanted something that reflected their fishing tradition so chose the winkle.

And in 1980, in Golcar in Huddersfield a new Winkle Club was formed following the Hastings model https://huddersfieldhub.co.uk/winkle-winkle-little-stars-how-a-strangely-named-group-is-spreading-the-magic-of-kindness-in-golcar/

Cute local custom, yes, but also some fundraising lessons

So what can we learn from this local custom

Make donating fun – can you add gamification so that there is a fun and competitive element to your campaigns? The tricks that Winklers tried to play on each other to catch each other out and make more money aided the campaign. This can incentivise people to be involved in campaigns but also creates a sense of community which helps build loyalty. The fun element adds an extra dopamine happy chemical hit to their giving experience.

Your identity as a Winkler is important and a shared local one – recognising other supporters like you is important – whether it is asking someone to ‘winkle up’ or seeing a supporter has the tote bag or a badge identifying them as another supporter. We like to have ways to identify our support and have social proof of what others like us do.

Celebrity winklers – having famous members helps promote your cause. Famous Winkle Club members include the late Queen, the Queen Mother, Norman Wisdom, Admiral Montgomery and Winston Churchill.

Adapt your offer to target segments of your supporters – Winston Churchill was presented with a special gold monogrammed winkle as an honorary member (see below) and the Queen was given a gold winkle made into a broach form. How can you treat special members differently to honour and recognise their status?

Picture above mine from visiting Chartwell and seeing Winston Churchil’s golden winkle – but to see a close up https://www.nationaltrustcollections.org.uk/object/1102834.1

News stories – make the most of getting press stories about ‘winkle up’ challenges especially from your famous members.

In 1953 at the dress rehearsal for the coronation Field Marshal Montgomery charged the Mayor of Dover to ‘winkle up’ – the mayor having been to several functions that day did not have his winkle in that pair of trousers and had to pay a fine (reported in the Hastings & St. Leonards Observer 6 June 1953 Pg. 0007)

In 2008, Admiral Boyce was answering questions at a government committee when an MP asked one final question – did he have his winkle with him? The Admiral did not so paid the fine – but the MP who asked the question – Hastings MP Michael Foster did not have his either so was also fined (there was also a light hearted debate about whether he ought to have been challenged when at work!) See curiosities here https://winkleclub.org/curiosities/

Rewards – both the current opportunities to donate that I saw to donate to the Winkle Club on a recent trip to Hastings are fun. Wishing wells and a giant winkle shell that makes a noise when you donate. Make your donation boxes fun, interactive and engaging.

Rhyme as the reason effect -using rhyming messages can make them more memorable.

Rhythm and rhymes

Aid us sometimes

By the means of acoustic encoding.

They help us just fine

To remember each line, 

Preventing our brains from exploding.

This rhyme comes from https://www.newscientist.com/lastword/mg24632811-700-time-for-a-rhyme/

And rhyme is used by the Winkle Club to ask you for a donation

Drop a coin into the Winkle

as a thank you the bell will give a tinkle

So winkle up!

https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/IMG_0527-scaled.jpeg 2560 1920 admin https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.png admin2024-03-26 07:57:122024-03-26 07:57:12Winkle Up!

Want to drive attraction and sales and make supporters fall in love?

September 28, 2023/0 Comments/in Thoughts/by admin

Then look no further that Donzetii’s gloriously fun and frothy opera L’elisir d’amore (The Elixir of Love)

Would you buy a love potion from this man?

Could you fall in love with this one?

The plot begins …

The opera tells the story of poor Nemerino who is desperately in love with wealthy landowner Adina who tells him she will never love him. The arrival of travelling salesman Dr Dulcamara and some universal elixir that promises to cure all ills and some cheap wine changes all of that. 

Why is Dulcamara such a good salesperson?

Why does Adina fall for Nemerino?


Let’s explore some behavioural and decision science and psychological principles at work in the story and see how they could be applied to fundraising and communications. 

(Now I appreciate that the centre of the Venn diagram of opera fans, Cialdini readers and behavioural psychology fans might be small, and this might be niche even for me, but there are some great heuristics at work that can be applied easily to communications and fundraising) 

So lets start with Dulcamara – he is a travelling salesman who goes from town to town selling a universal potion that claims to cure all ills.  

You can watch his sales pitch here – 4 mins long – (from the Royal Opera House’s production – ENO’s new production plays until 5 December 2024 and you can get tickets here)

And you can read an English translation here.

So what makes Dulcamara so successful as a salesperson?

He employs some psychological nudges to improve his credibility, authority and make you like and trust him more including:   

Authority – he assumes you have heard of him and  ‘what a great doctor I am’. He has ‘certificates authentic, branded, touch and see’ for you to see as testimonials to his success – these work as powerful messengers to attest to the success of the elixir. 

He celebrates his track record (‘because of me the hospitals are selling off their leases’) and lists all the diseases he can cure. 

‘The asthmatics, asphitics, hysterics and diabetics, cures the tympanitis, scrofula and rickets and even liver trouble… wonderful for liver, cures the paralytic, heals the apopletic’

There are so many cures listed that everyone and anyone could see something they suffer with being improved by application of the potion. 

Front cloth of the current L’elisir d’amore at the Royal Opera House with 50s style adverts for all the cures that Dulamara can provide.

Anchoring and priming 

‘Now you ask; what’s its price?

How much is it per bottle?

A hundred scudi ? … no.

Thirty? …. No.

Twenty? …. Now don’t be surprised’

This anchoring technique is a common sales technique used to influence the customer perception of the value of the item you want them to buy. Steve Jobs was clearly inspired by this technique when he announced the price of the newly launched iPad in 2010. He initially said the price was $999 before revealing that the price was only $499 – the high anchor made it seem like an expensive item and enhanced the perception of the quality and value of the item – the lower price makes it seem more affordable and reasonable. 

Incentive – Dulcamara was also offering a scudi cash back on any purchase which further incentivises a purchase. It also excites the reciprocity principle that the offer already has a concession made it in and therefore the natural human response is to reciprocate to the concession and accept the offer. 

Likability – Dulcamara seeks to let the crowd that he is like them and we like people who are more like us. He says all over Europe I sell for 9 lire “but as it is evident, I was born in the country, For three lire I grant you … ah warm homeland”. This again ignites the reciprocity principle as a concession, for being local, has already been made.

And what could you do to be more like Dulcamara?

(when we put aside the ethics of not overclaiming – your charity may be saving the world but you probably cannot claim to be a universal solution to all society’s ills) 

Authority –  what testimonials or awards have you for that enhance your credibility and speak of your successful track record? Awards or testimonials from others – industry leaders, participants or press – can act as powerful messengers.

Anchoring and priming – often supporters do not know what is appropriate to give so anchoring them and priming them with a number helps them know what to give. The Girl Guide cookie seller example if often cited with asking for thousands of dollars of cookie sales, which makes the follow up concession offer of $100 worth of cookies seem more reasonable and increases sales. How can you use larger numbers to help encourage bigger donations? Can you talk about the total cost of a programme, and then the cost of helping one child, one cat, save one square metre? The smaller number will seem more reasonable after the bigger number.

Likability– we like people who are like us. Highlighting his local connection makes Dulcamara more appealing. How can we show supporters that we are like them (or other people like them do this)? Fundraising research has shown in real world tests (with a public radio station in America) that if the person asking for money mentions the gender or location of the last donation e.g. when talking to a donor from Penzance saying, ‘I was just talking from someone from Penzance and she gave £50’ increases the donation rate. It highlights our identity – as a member of a place-based community – and also creates a powerful social norm of what people in our group, and our area do (one of the best ways to reduce electricity use was showing what other local people had already done). How can you highlight the local connection as a community? 

Reciprocity – what gift or offer can you give your supporters before hand? Is it a free pen, a sticker, a postcard, bookmark or are there are non-tangible warm glow affects you can give them about the impact of their previous work that makes that want to return the favour and reciprocate with a philanthropic gift?

And the plot continues …

Nemerino is desperately in love with Adina and after she has dismissed his suit he approaches Dulcamara for a love potion that will transform her affections. Dulcamara sells him the potion – which is in fact a cheap bottle of claret – Nemerino believing it will work its magic on Adina’s affections drinks it all and is dismissive of her.

The wine is a placebo – Nemerino believes the potion is working so does not try desperately hard to impress. By taking action and using the potion Nemerino has got the illusion of control over the unrequited love situation he finds himself in. (more about placebos here)

Some more plot

Nemerino’s rich uncle dies and leaves all his money and land to Nemerino (he is unaware of this)– the town get word of this and suddenly all the women of the village see Nemerino with new eyes and want to dance and flirt with him. 

Why does Adina fall in love with Nemerino?

Peer-suasian – once Adina sees all the women of the village finding Nemerino attractive and interesting she suddenly sees him in a new light. Humans are herd animals and seeing that everyone else thinks and reacts in a certain way has a powerful influence on us and our behaviours. Social ostracization is just as psychologically painful as physical pain so staying with the group is important. Adina becomes influenced by the others behaviours and questions her former apathy towards Nemerino. 

FOMO – we fear on missing out on something good. Adina fears that someone else will get Nemerino. (He has also sold himself to the army to get enough money to buy more elixir and Adina buys him back but says if she cannot love him he will still go to war and the soldiers have been summoned to action – so she fears she may lose him that way as well.)

And so why does Adina fall in love with Nemerino?

Apart from the tenor’s ability to sing beautifully – a combination of the social proof that he is an attractive proposition and the fear of missing out.  

So how could the implications of a love potion be used in fundraising?

  • Placebos – placebos are about trying to give the illusion of control – how can you more autonomy to your supporters about how they give, where they give, whether they give and when?
  • Peer-suasian – how can you show supporters that people like them (same age, location, demographic, gender) are supporting like you and that this is normal for people like that
  • Scarcity – how can a time limited match campaign or emergency situation galvanise that scarcity principles and drive action?
https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/image-1.png 1080 1080 admin https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.png admin2023-09-28 20:10:082024-11-10 13:57:52Want to drive attraction and sales and make supporters fall in love?

Pirate ransoms and fundraisers

September 19, 2023/0 Comments/in Thoughts/by admin

Did you know that in the sixteenth and seventeenth century people used to raise charitable funds to pay pirates’ ransom?

It raised questions in society of who ought to pay this fee – was it for the government and the king to pay on behalf of the nation? Or should it be funded by the family and friends? Or more generally from collected charitable funds?

Pirates and brigands in Algiers and the Barbary coast would attack and capture sailors and then send demands home. Without a ransom being paid the sailors would be enslaved and made to work. Pirates often targeted those that they thought of as wealthy to get a better result.

How much was a ransom? Between 200-500 ducats.

The government refused to negotiate with pirates, so it was up to the family and friends to raise the funds to pay the ransom. But wondering from town to town asking for support could have you imprisoned for vagrancy in England so a solution was found in crown and church supported ‘briefs’ which the families of kidnapped sailors could apply for. The brief detailed the case and allowed you to petition in various locations – it is an early form of funding regulation and licence. They could then beg alms to pay the ransom – and also receive charitable donations to support their own upkeep.

There was a suspicion that these briefs were open to abuse and not really issued to those who needed them, or sold on for ready cash so these petitions could be refused.

The cause was popular in maritime towns and local authorities. Livery companies, royal decrees, legacies, published sermons and church collections also supported the impacted individuals raising funds.

Some examples:

  • 1567 the Bishop of London, Edmund Grindal, supported a brief on behalf of the captives in Algiers.
  • 1570s – £70-£100 a year raised by London livery companies to support the rescues.
  • 1568 2 shillings were given by the churchwardens at Ashburton in Devon ‘to one that gathered them for them that be in Turkey’ in response to a brief
  • 1619 – 9d given by County Durham Churchwardens for ransom and 12d for the maintenance of the wife of the ransomed sailor
  • 1636 – a series of Charles FitzGeffrey’s sermons were published to raise funds to save enslaved and captured sailors – saying it was their Christian duty to free the captives as Jesus has redeemed mankind from the bondage of sin.
  • 1669 – £100 a year forever was left in Alice, Duchess Dudley’s will to free captives (I wonder what happened to that)
  • 1686 – £3000 left in the will of former Admiralty officer Sir William Coventry to redeem captives.
  • 1683 – £1 towards the £100 ransom was raised when widow Elizabeth Newman appealed directly to the Earl of Bedford

What is charitable and what you can raise and do raise money for is historically and culturally situated and evolves over time.

What might happen with a pirate’s ransom now? A crowdfunder?

https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/09/pirates-band-of-misfits.png 172 400 admin https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.png admin2023-09-19 15:54:422024-12-05 16:06:14Pirate ransoms and fundraisers

Summer Reading Challenge: Fundraising edit (fiction)

August 22, 2023/0 Comments/in What I'm Reading/by admin

Completing the library summer reading challenge with the children – where primary school aged children need to read six books over the summer and get stickers and a medal. I was thinking about what would make a fundraising reading challenge.

Too often when fundraising appears in fiction it is a negative way – corruption, begging, ‘psychic blackmail’, self-interest, brand building, giving for guilt or spite, ‘cookie pusher’ (seen below in Lego form), attending charity events with no sense of the charity or cause, and generally reinforcing negative stereotypes about motives and efficacy of charities. They often show how charity is embedded into the fabric of our society and how we interact with them – one of the most frequent is donating unwanted things to charity shops.

However, stories have a powerful impact on us and the way in which we see and experience the world. This is something is called cultivation theory – and our perception of the world around us is learnt from the culture we consume which we unconsciously mimic. When we are watching theatre and seeing stories come to life we have increased empathy for the people in the stories, their issues and it changes political attitudes.

We become, in a sense, what we read or consume– so a summer reading challenge to celebrate fundraising in and philanthropy fiction.

However, amongst the general negativity, there are some stories that celebrate and champion fundraisers and fundraising and what can be achieved.

Here are a few…

 ‘A fairy godmother is just another word for a philanthropist. A rich person who gives money to causes’

Lessons in Chemistry

  • Being described as charitable can be a shortcut to saying someone is a good person such as Lady Russell in Persuasion
  • Lessons in Chemistry and the impact of academic grants to succeed (more on that here)
  • Great donor stewardship seen in personalised thank you notes from the CEO in Best of Friends by Kamila Shamsie
  • Positive community action and fundraising to save a local business in The Book Lovers by Emily Henry
  • Employment and opportunity by a particular legacy gift in J L Carr A Month in the Country
  • Fundraisers as charming in Death and the Penguin by Andrey Kurkov
  • Fundraisers as a job in Lost in A Good Book by Jasper Fforde
  • Hermione founding the The Society for the Promotion of Elfish Welfare and campaigning for societal change in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire
  • Donor care in Trust by Hernan Diaz
  • All gifts of whatever size being appreciated and valued in Rodham by Curtis Sittenfeld
  • A great exploration of what to do with wealth and working for a non profit in Pineapple Street by Jenny Jackson

First lines featuring fundraising

… so I am not sure these will rival dreaming of Manderley, possessing a fortune and wanting a wife, or the best of times but two stories that begin with fundraising

“Film legend and ‘60s It Girl Everyn Huge has just announced she will auction off 12 of her most memorable gowns through Christie’s to raise money for breast cancer research” 7 Husbands of Evelyn Hardcastle

And how’s this for a (philanthropic) first line?

‘It was one of those sweltering days toward the end of the fiscal year when Minneapolis smells of melting asphalt and foundation money is as tight as a rusted nut’ Jack Schmidt, Arts Administrator

And, a counter argument to too many books talking about high overheads

The Diamond Brothers in the Blurred Man and I know what you did last Wednesday by Anthony Horowitz

“It was hard to believe that a charity worth millions of pounds could operate from such a small, shabby place. But maybe that was the point. Maybe they didn’t want to spend the money they raised on plush offices in the West End. It’s the same reason Oxfam shops always look run down. That way they can afford another ox”  

How do we give money away … if you had millions… two literary suggestions for how to explore the issues

Howard’s End– as an after party diner game ‘How ought I to dispose of my money?’ with the host pretending to be a millionaire on the point of death discussing and debating how to dispose of the fortune and young Margaret Schlegel advises cash and the autonomy for individuals to choose what they need:

“Give them a chance. Give them money. Don’t dole them out poetry books and railway tickets like babies/ Give them the wherewithal to buy these things … give people cash, for it is the warp of civilisation whatever the woof may be”

Thanks to Rhodri Davis for this example.

Just My Luck how much of a £12.8m lottery win do you give to charity and how do you decide which ones have the most impact

And a few bits of fundraising history unearthed through fiction

  • Spitfire Crowdfunding campaign in The Whalebone Theatre by Joanna Quinn (which you can read more about here and how a blank cheque sparked a fundraising revolution https://marinajones.uk/spitfirefund/ or listen to this to learn more Spitfire: The People’s Plane – Crowdfunding – BBC Sounds)
  • Raising funds for a highway from The Lincoln Highway by Amor Towles which inspired this blog It really is true everything is a project in fundraising … but could you fundraise for a motorway? – Marina Jones

In contrast to the actual summer reading challenge which for the second year in a row doesn’t have cartoon children reading (there is at least a book in the picture this year). Here I am reading….

So … If we saw more positive portrayals of fundraising and charities in novels would it improve more people’s perception of fundraising and the good we do?

If you want to read more about how what you watch and read impacts you, here are three further sources.

  • Theatre making us more philanthropic and empathetic The Science of Live Theatre | Psychology Today
  • An academic analysis of volunteering on TV Portrayals of Volunteering on U.S. Television: A Textual Analysis – Kimberly Wiley, Marissa Evans, 2022 (sagepub.com)
  • How children learn about charity, philanthropy and voluntary action an assessment of the literature Philanthropic tales: A critical analysis of how philanthropic citizenship is represented in children’s picture-books – problems and possibilities – Alison Body, Jayne Lacny, 2023 (sagepub.com)

For more examples of how fundraising, charity and philanthropy appears in fiction and in films and tv, you can follow my other account on twitter/X under ‘Philanthropy in fiction’ and follow a rather haphazard approach to interrogating what stories tell us about fiction.

https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/08/cookie-eyes.jpg 32 180 admin https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.png admin2023-08-22 18:12:252024-07-23 18:13:21Summer Reading Challenge: Fundraising edit (fiction)
Page 1 of 212
Tweets by meenamtj
All content © Marina Jones 2023
  • Link to X
  • Link to Instagram
  • Link to LinkedIn
Scroll to top Scroll to top Scroll to top

This site uses cookies. By continuing to browse the site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies.

Accept settingsHide notification onlySettings

Cookie and Privacy Settings



How we use cookies

We may request cookies to be set on your device. We use cookies to let us know when you visit our websites, how you interact with us, to enrich your user experience, and to customize your relationship with our website.

Click on the different category headings to find out more. You can also change some of your preferences. Note that blocking some types of cookies may impact your experience on our websites and the services we are able to offer.

Essential Website Cookies

These cookies are strictly necessary to provide you with services available through our website and to use some of its features.

Because these cookies are strictly necessary to deliver the website, refusing them will have impact how our site functions. You always can block or delete cookies by changing your browser settings and force blocking all cookies on this website. But this will always prompt you to accept/refuse cookies when revisiting our site.

We fully respect if you want to refuse cookies but to avoid asking you again and again kindly allow us to store a cookie for that. You are free to opt out any time or opt in for other cookies to get a better experience. If you refuse cookies we will remove all set cookies in our domain.

We provide you with a list of stored cookies on your computer in our domain so you can check what we stored. Due to security reasons we are not able to show or modify cookies from other domains. You can check these in your browser security settings.

Google Analytics Cookies

These cookies collect information that is used either in aggregate form to help us understand how our website is being used or how effective our marketing campaigns are, or to help us customize our website and application for you in order to enhance your experience.

If you do not want that we track your visit to our site you can disable tracking in your browser here:

Other external services

We also use different external services like Google Webfonts, Google Maps, and external Video providers. Since these providers may collect personal data like your IP address we allow you to block them here. Please be aware that this might heavily reduce the functionality and appearance of our site. Changes will take effect once you reload the page.

Google Webfont Settings:

Google Map Settings:

Google reCaptcha Settings:

Vimeo and Youtube video embeds:

Other cookies

The following cookies are also needed - You can choose if you want to allow them:

Privacy Policy

You can read about our cookies and privacy settings in detail on our Privacy Policy Page.

Privacy Policy
Accept settingsHide notification only