Here I am aged 6 at the Minack Theatre in Cornwall in a production of Juluis Caesar. Can you spot me? This production was directed by my father, and also in the picture is my mother, sister and grandfather.
This is taken from Act Three of Julius Caesar just after Caesar has been assassinated by the conspirators. Mark Antony has just finished the famous “Friends, Romans, countrymen, lend me your ears” speech, and the crowd are shouting to hear Caesar’s will. Mark Antony was not one of the conspirators who assassinated Caesar, and in the space of this one scene through the power of speech he changes the angry mob from thinking Caesar was a tyrant, to a champion of Rome and the people. The speech itself is a masterclass in persuasive oratory.
At this point the crowd are yelling “We’ll hear the will. Read it, Mark Antony” and “The will, the will! We will hear Caesar’s will” (notice the deliberate repetition of ‘will’ when ‘shall’ would make more grammatical sense).
So what was in Caesar’s will, how did Romans make legacy gifts, and how could you be as persuasive as Mark Antony in your fundraising?
Let’s pick three devices used by Mark Antony to persuade the crowd:
Framing
“I come to bury Caesar, not to praise him.”
Framing is the context or lens which people use to understand a message. Just as a picture frame changes how a painting is perceived, the “frame” we use alters how our audience sees the facts.
For example, an operation with a 90% survival rate sounds far more positive than one with a 10% mortality rate, even though the facts are identical.
By Mark Antony saying he has come “to bury, not to praise,” Antony appears neutral, framing his speech as respectful compliance with Brutus and the conspirators. This disarms Brutus, and the crowd’s defences.
He also reframes “ambition” which is a negative quality when Brutus uses it. Brutus and the conspirators claim that Caesar’s ambition to be emperor was cause for the assassination. Mark Antony contrasts Brutus’ claims of “ambition” with Caesar’s refusal of the crown and his generosity to the city.
In fundraising, the frame that we put around a problem can help a donor understand the issue, and drive action. So instead of “2 million starving children need help today”, we can frame the problem as “Help Ifran have a meal today” (this links into the identifiable victimheuristic where we are more likely to help one named person rather than countless millions. Our brains cannot compute the big numbers or the scale of such a large problem – but, by the frame helps adds focus and by using the lens of how we can help one child (Ifran) we can see a tangible and real impact of our gift.)
Repetition
“Yet Brutus says he was ambitious; And Brutus is an honourable man.”
Repetition breeds familiarity and our brains often equate familiarity with truth. This is known as the mere-exposure effect. Antony deliberately repeats Brutus’ assertion that Caesar was ambitious, until it sounds hollow and insincere. By overusing it, he drains it of its original power and turns it back on its speaker.
Mark Antony calls Brutus “an honourable man” not once, not twice, but eight times.
In fundraising, we often debate how many times to repeat an ask — but repetition works. Despite how carefully you have crafted your appeal your donor will skim it (see the work of Siegfried Vögele). So although it might feel repetitious to you (or to someone else in the organisation reading it) knowing that your donor is skimming your material makes repetition powerful and effective.
Mark Antony
Curiosity
“I found it in his closet. ’Tis his will.”
At first Mark Antony refuses to read the will. This incites the curiosity of the crowd:
“Have patience, gentle friends. I must not read it. It is not meet you know how Caesar loved you. You are not wood, you are not stones, but men. And, being men, hearing the will of Caesar, It will inflame you; it will make you mad.”
This leverages the curiosity effect our innate drive to seek information simply because we want to know what we don’t. Curiosity triggers dopamine release, increasing engagement, memory, and motivation.
In fundraising curiosity can be in the teasers or questions you ask in your appeals and communications
“How just £1 saved 20 people in Ethiopia from certain death?”
Mark Antony’s rhetoric also feeds into reactance. When we are told that we cannot, or should not, have something it feels like our agency and autonomy is being taken away, and we rebel against it and want to do the opposite. So, by Mark Antony telling the crowd that they cannot hear the will makes them want to know what is in the will even more.
When asking for donations we need to be careful not to incite reactance in our donors making them feel that they do not have agency in the decision. A meta data study by Roger Dooley that looked at 22,000 pieces of data showed that by giving donor’s permission not to give, or not to give now by adding the phrase ‘but you are free to choose’ increased donations x2.
What does Caesar’s will tell us about Roman wills?
“Here is the will, and under Caesar’s seal: To every Roman citizen he gives, To every several man, seventy-five drachmas.”
The will reveals that Caesar left each Roman citizen 75 drachmas. Caesar also left his private orchards and gardens to the city to enjoy.
“Moreover, he hath left you all his walks, His private arbors, and new-planted orchards, On this side Tiber. He hath left them you, And to your heirs forever—common pleasures To walk abroad and recreate yourselves. Here was a Caesar! When comes such another”
Although Shakespeare is known for his fabrication of historical events for political propaganda, Mark Antony is really reported to have read Caesar’s will and the contents described are accurate in the play. However, in real life, Mark Antony read it in private, but the contents were made public.
Roman wills, like wills today, were socially and culturally prescribed. The norms that we see today to gift to immediate family (prescribed through legitimate portions in some countries) date back from Roman customs. Wills were important documents for securing succession and naming official heirs.
Charitable works for the public good, like leaving the land to the city or building theatres or libraries, was a key virtue in Roman society so there was a cultural norm to make gifts like this it was a way in which powerful men (and a few women) demonstrated their civic virtue.
It was also common practice that wills gave freedom to your faithful slaves
Some other Roman legacy examples:
As with many parts of the history of fundraising and philanthropy, we rely on what survived to catch glimpses of the past and what and how fundraising and charitable giving was carried out. Inscriptions on tombs can give us clues to how philanthropy was enacted when the papyri have long since disintegrated. There are a few notable examples of legacy giving – like Caesar’s – that reflect in life commitments.
Menodora
Menodora’s tomb
In Turkey a tomb was recently discovered with an inscription which tells of Menodora, a woman in the town of Sillyon who donated over 300,000 denarii to a children’s foundation and building public monuments (via Why Philanthropy Matters newsletter)
Pliny the Younger, prolific first century letter writer, lawyer, author, magistrate and sometime philanthropist, is a notable legacy donor. Pliny’s will details his bequests for the public good including gifts to the public baths and their upkeep (we like a legacy bequest that comes with maintenance costs.) In his will, he also supported Freemen of the city which included spend on an annual dinner. In his life he had been a major contributor to the library and his will does not include another gift to the library but notes his life time gifts which included 100,000 sesterii for the upkeep of the library.
To read more about legacies and history
“Let’s choose executors and talk of wills.” – this quote from Shakespeare’s Richard II is quoted on a Salvation Army legacy brochure from 90 years https://marinajones.uk/legacy90/
We have a tendency to think of wills as private documents, especially in British culture. Philanthropist and entrepreneur Madam CJ Walker was aware it is a public document and will be read and scrutinised https://marinajones.uk/legacylessons/
https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/11/IMG_0318.jpeg8911260adminhttps://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.pngadmin2025-11-10 19:53:012025-11-10 19:53:12Read the will Mark Antony!
You have heard of natural selection?And the survival of the fittest?
What about ‘socioemotional selection’?
Have you ever done it?
What does it mean?
When time is unlimited we follow knowledge based goals, but when time is limited – as you near the end of a job, college, university, or your life – emotional goals become more important. This impacts on who you want to spend that limited time with, and which relationships you hold onto.
So, as you near the end of a degree, you are not so interested in meeting and spending time with first years, and want to enjoy the final moments with those you have been with for the last three years. Or as you finish a job that you have had for many years, you want to spend time with those closest to you rather than meeting lots of new people.
Think back to when you have been in this situation – did you start to select like this? Focus on those nearest and dearest?
That is socioemotional selectivity. A theory proposed and tested by social scientists Laura T Cartesen, Derek M Issacowitz and Susan T Charles.
It links to behavioural economics Kahmenan and Tvesky’s prospect theory where we weigh up the potential losses or gains of any decision we make.
When time is open ended then new relationships hold more potential for gains – but when time is limited then there is no such gain and we focus on the known gains from the known relationships.
And it is important to recognise it in ourselves, and also in our donors.
And knowing more about it can help you think about fundraising?
There is a commonly held myth about older people. That as they get older there social networks shrink as their friends die off.
From ‘When’ by Daniel H Pink
However, more focussed studies of social networks in older people show a more nuanced pattern. When mapped in more detail to show those social networks divided into the inner friendship group and the outer friendship group – the inner circle remains pretty constant throughout our life cycle in terms of size of network. It is the outer circle that starts to shrink. When time is limited we prioritise those that we have a closer relationship with.
From ‘When’ by Daniel H Pink
This is an active elimination of the outer circle.
A pruning of relationships.
“When time is constrained and limited, as it is at act three [final act], we attune to the now. We pursue different goals – emotional satisfaction, an appreciation for life, a sense of meaning”
‘When’ by Daniel H Pink
So when the end if near, and its time to face the final curtain. We don’t want lots of new transitory relationships or acquaintances – we want the ones that mean something
“We edit relationships. We omit needless people. We choose to spend our remaining years with networks that are small, tight and populated with those that satisfy our higher needs”
‘When’ by Daniel H Pink
Are older or younger people more able to remember emotional material?
The older you are the more emotional recall you have.
‘older people recall more than younger people about their thoughts and feelings’
Laura T Cartesen, Derek M Issacowitz and Susan T Charles
When older people took part in a memory paradigm test – a test involving reading a two page summary of a novel and then recalling the information. Older people recalled more of the emotional material than the non-emotional material (so younger people remembered more facts and less feelings.) So remember to keep communicating the emotions to your older supporters. The more emotional = the more memorable.
Time to prune?
So back to socioemotional selection – this findings struck a chord with me as I have seen donors and supporters do it – in life, and with final gifts in legacies.
We had a very lovely donor in her 80s who was philanthropically very active supporting a number of charities that were important to her – cultural, civil rights, medical. As she became older, and her 90th birthday was approaching, there was a conscious and active pruning of the causes that she could support. She did not have the time, or the energy (even though she was out at the theatre several times a week!) to continue to support all of the charities she had done. She made choices about who retained her support – these were connected to her enjoyment, her profession, and how those in the fundraising teams made her feel. As we can see, when time is limited, we focus on the relationships that mean the most.
There was also a practical element in this pruning –as a great theatre lover and as she was aging, her mobility decreased and she could only attend venues where a taxi could take her to the main entrance and the lack of access provided by some venues made attendance impossible. This stopped her going to some places that she had been going all her life (and performed in) and consequently stopped her giving. Not all these things are in your control, but they are important, and how older supporters might perceive or experience your services from physical access to fonts matters.
Socioemotional selection is also important when it comes to legacy giving. Being in the will is important, but being in the last and final will is crucial. Often charities have been told that they are in the will, and they may have been. But data shows a real gap between those that thought they are in the will, and those that get a gift – Legacy Foresight sighting 50% of gifts pledged in will are never realised (2019). One reason is socioemotional selection and this pruning stage. On average people write three wills in their lifetime, the final one being aged 80+. At this stage, with time being limited, the charities that are still meaningful, that have made an impact, that have stayed in touch, that are stewarding, that they still engage with and that there is a sense of relationship are more likely to make the final cut. That is why continued stewardship of your supporters is so crucial.
A historic bad example of failing to maintain the relationship from New York
Super fans, super loyal but also need super care
Since the 1950s Lois Kirschenbaum attended nearly every performance and always hung around stage door to get her programme or ticket signed. She was an opera super fan, although the data collected would not have shown her up as a potential major legacy giver. Lois Kirschenbaum bought standing places. She was legally blind and watched the opera through big binoculars. She lived in a rent controlled apartment, worked for a charity and caught the bus to the opera. However the lived frugally and left $4m to 18 charities giving $1.7m to the arts but not to the Met Opera because of a decision 30 yrs ago not to let her backstage to continue to gather the signatures she loved. Often legacy pledgers are not big donors in their lifetime but their gifts reflect a lifetime of connection.
And an important reminder that those who have already made a commitment to you with a gift in their will, have made a mental adjustment of how they see you, that you are already a more meaningful and more deeply help connection as they start to give more in their lifetime. Including that bequest has drawn you closer to them but even then you can fall out in this pruning stage
Thinking about your supporters, would you survive a socioemotional selection cut?
How can how you look after your donors and the connections that you make mean that yours is the charity that they stay supporting – in life and in death?
https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2025/01/pruning-garden-1521648761.jpg10602121adminhttps://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.pngadmin2025-01-27 08:54:252025-08-03 15:32:25Don’t be the charity that gets pruned
When we get Christmas money, or birthday money, that’s different money, right?
We set that money aside physically or mentally – it is not something we would spend on buying the milk, or the everyday. We frame it differently.
£20 Christmas money can still buy the loaf of bread, but we have reserved it our minds for a treat.
We constantly assign the money we have in our bank accounts to different pots – based on its origin, or intended use.
This is called ‘mental accounting’ and first described by economist Richard Thaler.
Technically money is fungible – that means it is interchangeable – any £10 note is the same as any other £10 notes but we don’t treat it as such.
Here are a few examples of it in literature to show how we think about money in different ways and how the source of money taints the gift.
In the Bible Judas receives thirty silver coins for the betrayal of Jesus in the Garden of Gethsemane. After his crucifixion he returns the money to the chief priests but they do not want it because
“The chief priests picked up the coins and said, “It is against the law to put this into the treasury, since it is blood money.” 7 So they decided to use the money to buy the potter’s field as a burial place for foreigners. 8 That is why it has been called the Field of Blood to this day.
Matthew 27
In Margaret Mitchell’s Gone With the Wind – Belle Watling the brothel owner wants to make her contribution towards the war effort but it is has been refused because of her profession and how she earned it. She goes to Melly Hamilton at night and in secret to hand the money over secretly saying ‘It’s good money even if it’s mine.’
In East Lynne by Ellen Wood, Mr Carlyle receives damages in his divorce from the man who runs off with his wife. He does not keep the money and it goes straight to the county hospital.
The source of those gifts makes the money unacceptable or problematic to accept.
But we all do this to an extent with our own money – with allocations for holiday, entertainment, charity or hobbies. We think about our money like this.
And this also applies to how we think about giving money to charity – we have a charitable allocation (formal or informal) in our mental accounts.
Even within the charity (mental) account we can allocate to different causes that reflect different areas of change for good we want to see in the world. These allocations might link to different parts of our story and identifies – as fighters for justice, as searchers for a cure, or lovers of art. We also may have the sunk cost of a monthly payment to a charity we love. That money is already spent and assigned in our mental charity account, so when the emergency appeal or match campaign lands we can assign that need to a different part of our mental charitable account.
As this legacy pledger articulates:
“So we gave some money to Oxfam for international development. Then he said ‘human rights is what I want’ … and then so I thought OK we’ve got international development, we’ve got human rights, great I can leave something to culture. And this was the one where I’d had the most pleasure by then over the years”
The language you use when asking supporters to help you change the world for the better can help them mentally assign it to different parts of their (charity) budgets. If we think about this when writing inspiring appeals then we can tap into different mental accounts and make it easier for people to give, and give more.
There are also other mental accounts that the money could come from – does the gala ticket come from the ‘charity’ mental account? or the leisure/entertainment one? Does the raffle ticket come from charity or ‘spare change’ or gambling or indulgence?
A fact that I love is that after adding a gift in their will, donors give more in their lifetime to that charity – by 77%! It is as if you have moved mental accounts once this commitment has been made, and are being treated as a member of the family (fundraisers can be reluctant to ask for legacy gifts fearing it will impact in year gifts but the reverse is true)
The Emerging Potential of Longitudinal Empirical Research in Estate Planning: Examples from Charitable Bequests Russell N. James III*
Think about the ways that you can make your charitable asks meet these different mental accounting pots.
https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/12/IMG_3662-1.jpeg11141144adminhttps://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.pngadmin2024-12-24 13:00:382024-12-29 15:39:20Christmas money is different to other money…?
Any gift you can give make whatever size makes a huge difference…
And we are asked to know what 1p, £1, or £1m could do for our cause.
What difference do these micro-donations make?
Is microphilanthropy a new thing?
First what is a microphilanthropy? The clue is in the name they are small gifts. It has been defined, in the US, as gifts from 25c to $10, and is sometimes called ‘spare change philanthropy’.
Recent technological advances claim to have revolutionised the microphilanthropy giving space – from Amazon Smile, to rounding up at the supermarket, the ways we can make frequent small donations has expanded. But from the Biblical widow’s mite, small gifts have been making a mighty impact on the philanthropic landscape – and not just on how much we raise, but how we engage with supporters.
A note on size of gift – micro in monetary value does not mean it has no meaning to your donor, or charity. In the Biblical account (Luke 21:1-4), Jesus describes a poor widow putting in two small coins to the Temple collection and says
“Truly I say to you that this poor widow has put in more than all; for all these out of their abundance have put in offerings for God, but she out of her poverty put in all the livelihood that she had.”
Just because gifts are small in monetary value does not mean that are not significant amounts to our donors.
Here are two historic examples of regular microdonations from fundraising history. They illustrate why these are powerful tools that we can use to build the philanthropic tribe, and explore why they work.
Salvation Army – Grace Before Meat
As part of its encouragement of regular and mindful giving, the Salvation Army mass produced ‘Grace Before Meat’ donation boxes in the late Victorian period. These were to be put out on the table, so that when the family was saying grace before a meal they would be reminded of those less fortunate, and develop the regular habit of putting a small donation in the box. Salvation Army collectors regularly visited houses with these boxes to collect the takings.
British Red Cross – Penny a Week
During the Second World War the Duke of Gloucester spearheaded a Penny-a-Week campaign for the British Red Cross. This worked through habitual donations, people knocking at the door to solicit the penny a week and was also via Trade Unions introduced as one of the earliest form of payroll giving.
Why do these schemes work?
Habits and Behavioural bundling – we find it easier to do something if we do it regularly with another behaviour, for example you can only listen to your favourite podcast when you go to the gym, or treat yourself to a sweet treat when visiting with a relation you don’t like. Coupling two behaviours together helps us maintain and sustain them which is why the Salvation Army ‘Grace Before Meat’ works so well – they are linked and repeated. This form of giving also has the added bonus of linking to our natural human desire to reciprocate – we think ‘I am about to eat a lovely meal, I can do something nice for others who do not have what I have’. (Today we see it with Giving Tuesday, hot on the heels of Black Friday – the need to do something good for the world after indulging in the consumerist excess of purchasing gifts for yourself and loved ones.)
Social signifier – the ‘Grace Before Meat’ donation box and the ‘Penny a Week’ collecting box could be put on display demonstrating to anyone visiting your house how philanthropic and charitable you were. And encouraging visitors to give as well.
Norming and conforming behaviour – the more you see these boxes, or the thank you badges that people were rewarded with or pre printed receipts sent out by the Duke of Gloucester the more normal this behaviour was seen amongst your social group and the more you would want to imitate it by supporting, or getting your own donation box.
Pattern completion – humans want to create and complete patterns. Have you ever done a 30 day Yoga challenge? Or filled a Smartie’s tubes with 20ps for Brownies? Or spend extra time at a museum to complete the stamp trail? We want to complete the challenge. We have made that the commitment, whether publicly or privately, and feel duty bound to stick to it. So completing a time limited giving of a ‘Penny a Week’ feels like both an achievable goal, one that we have committed to, and once we start we do not want to break the pattern!
The Goldilocks effect of friction …
The Goldilocks effect says we don’t want too much, or too little, like Golilocks and the porridge in the fairy story, we want the middle option that is ‘just right’
Often with giving we talk about reducing the friction and effort that the donor needs to make to give you a gift – if it is too hard, too many clicks, too many forms to fill in then it it is ‘too hard’. and donors lose patience and abandon the gift.
On the other hand. it can be ‘too easy’ and requires too little thought or engagement and the donor might not know what charity they gave to, how much or why.
So sometimes, like Goldilocks, you need the ‘just right’ amount of friction – what is powerful about these two historical examples is that they require a low level of repeated effort – just the right amount of friction – to engage with donating.
It is important to remember for every donation you give you get a hit of the happy chemicals (dopamine, oxytocin, serotonin and endorphins). So a microdonation of microphilanthropy = microdose of happy chemicals. Once someone is signed up for a Direct Debit – donors can forget about it. Seeing it on the bank statement doesn’t give you the ‘warm glow’ or the same rush of happy chemicals as the active act of giving. How can you keep that happy hit going by just the right amount of friction?
And remember when it comes to these small micro donations … every penny does make a difference
Over 1million EUROS are donated through coins in the Trevi fountain each year which supports Caritas which amongst other things provides 100 families a day with access to a free supermarket.
When the Roman Baths in Bath banned throwing coins into the water donations went down £90,000
How could you use this in your fundraising?
How can you remind people regularly of the joy of giving and what their donation does?
How can you provide an option to round up?
Interestingly rounding up helps reduce the psychological pain of paying – and as humans we prefer round numbers. At petrol pumps 56% of transactions end in a round number, we round tips up to a round number and supermarket donations.
How can you provide regular injections of the happy chemicals to your supporters?
How can you bundle the giving behaviour with another behaviour – a treat for them, or encourage them to give for a duration?
How can giving help the donor signify to the wider world their identity and who they are?
How can you help donors complete a pattern of giving? A durational gift?
How can you include good friction into your supporter journey to connect with supporters?
https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/OIG3.7p6GwWXt5AzuzZikWPX7.jpeg10241024adminhttps://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.pngadmin2024-10-24 18:16:072024-10-24 18:16:07Every little helps …. Microphilanthropy then and now
We all know that money appears in funny ways to fundraisers. Funny times and funny amounts.
We also know that donors don’t always know how much we need, what is the most appropriate amount to give, what will make a difference.
To make things easier for a donor and to reduce the brain power needed to process these decisions – we break down gifts into tangible amounts so that the donor can see the impact of what they are giving – a life changing vaccine, a warm meal, restoring a square inch of a Renaissance masterpiece, a new theatre or scanner. Their contribution to the wider problem and how they can help solve it becomes meaningful and concrete (something called then concreteness effect).
From a behavioural insight point of view, we want to keep the process friction free and easy for the donor’s brain to process and make the gift. Our brains are lazy and like to stay in the automatic system one intuitive space – it uses far more energy and slows us down to move into a more analytical space and ask questions about the amount. But sometime friction can be a good thing in the donation process.
This is a powerful and effective tool – and one that we should keep using.
However, this approach also makes it about us and what we need.
It makes it about us the charity, not them the donor.
What if we make it more about the donor?
Their choice of an amount that is meaningful to them.
When testing ask strings – I tested a £20, £50, £100 ask string and then a £100, £50, £20 knowing that the science should show that the higher anchor (starting with £100) generated a higher average donation as donor’s saw the highest number first. 97% of the time we saw people did not change from the preset defaulted numbers. But when the anchors were removed and the donation amount was left empty we saw much higher average donations.
People give in amounts that are salient to them (not always to you and the campaign)
Here are a few historic examples:
Edward I on his son’s 14th birthday fed fourteen hundred paupers, and when his son was 17, gave alms to seventeen hundred people
Edward III on his 50th birthday 50 poor men get shoes to celebrate
Worth your weight in diamonds. There is an ancient Hindu ritual where individuals were weighed against gold or grain and made a donation equivalent to their weight – this is known as tulabhara and often people did it on their birthdays. There was a custom to weigh the king on his solar and lunar birthdays in precious stones (and in diamonds for a diamond jubilee) and the jewels sold and monies given to charity. You can see the ceremony from 1946 on this newsreel https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IEkdZlWCd4I&t=116s
We see these grain offerings in sixth century of Europe as well in the writings of Gregory of Tours which also records the tradition of weighing a donor for gifts. This is also done as a thank offering for recovering from being sick. The Abess of St Servatius was weighed at Our Lady of Buurkeerk in Amsterdam in 1444 to determine the amount the donation.
Legacy doles of food to the poor often fall on the testator’s birthday, for example, Elizabeth Nickus in c19th Bristol.
In 1393, wool merchant Marco Carelli signed over his entire fortune to the fabric fund at Milan cathedral living the last two years of his live as a pauper. The date he signed the declaration – the Assumption – the day that Mary, mother of Jesus was taken up to heaven – to reflect his donation to Our Lady that the cathedral was dedicated to. The choice of date matters.
In Liverpool, during the Second World War, funds were raised to fund Spitfires to fight the Nazis. At a police station a gift was left ‘for the Spitfire Fund’ by a “lady of the night” – the amount? £3 which was the standard fine for soliciting.
When we think about annual giving we tend to think of a gift every year – but this 82 year old admiral turned that on its head (in 1867) when asked by a missionary collector for a gift he said “a guinea a year” – he gave 82 guineas one for each year of his life. Again a number salient to him rather than the collection.
More recently we have seen Swifties (fans of Taylor Swift) support causes close to Taylor’s heart giving in $13 amounts. $13 is Taylor Swift’s favourite number so it an important way of identifying your philanthropy and allying with your ally and what they stand for. Taylor Swift also donates in $1989 amounts – linking to her album and birth date.
In the National Theatre’s campaign they proposed making annual donations on Shakespeare Day (23 April) to support the creation of the theatre.
1891 Blackburn Orphanage founded and in 1892 started a Pound Day asking people to donate a £1 and those that could not afford to were asked to donate a pound of sugar, tea or flour or whatever they could afford.
What might be going on in a donor’s brain here?
Part of it is there are just numbers that mean something to us and our identity – our age, our favourite number, an important date (I have one charitable direct debit that deliberately goes on a certain date).
There is also an effect known as the Ikea effect – named after the furniture store – where we value something more because we have helped create it. So we value a Billy Bookcase more because of our involvement in constructing it.
How can donors help construct the gifts they give – the amount, the date?
Sometimes too prescriptive a list can cause reactance – when we react against being told what to do. Sometimes the list does not give us the option we want – the options are too small and not meaningful enough, or too big and beyond our capacity.
When we give donor’s the autonomy and empower them to make a choice they can make gifts that are more personally meaningful to them.
People want autonomy and agency and choosing the amount gives them that.
However, how this choice is presented is important. If it is too open an offer such as ‘pay what you feel‘ we might nudge the brain into a system two space and ask ‘how do I feel about this? and what value does that mean? And by pausing to ask these questions we have no frame of reference and can stop and not make the decision.
The frame of the question is important here.
How could you give your donor’s more autonomy and choice about how they make a gift and how much?
How can you invite them to make gifts that mean more to them?
So testing what works for your audience and donors works.
When Greenpeace in Argentina ran a telephone campaign seeking one off gifts they tested various options including Mother’s Day, National Argentina day – and the one that got the highest donations was gifts linked to their pet’s birthday.
So perhaps there is a blended way to offer a combination of the standard anchoring, defaults and social norms with some nudging towards a personally meaningful amount.
How do you make it about them?
Not about you?
https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/its-me-1.jpg604604adminhttps://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.pngadmin2024-05-26 09:27:182026-03-20 21:07:24It’s not you, its me
Would you ever write a blank cheque? Or have you ever received a blank cheque from a donor?
In August 1940 16 spitfires had been shot down in the English Channel and 13 pilots were killed Horrified by what he saw, Garfield Weston reacted – yes that Garfield Weston of the Garfield Weston Foundation that has given away over £2bn to good causes. At that time he was a businessman, entrepreneur and also a member of parliament in the UK.
Garfield Weston gave a blank cheque to Lord Beaverbrook saying:
‘All I can say is that I’ve a blank cheque here. You know, Max, only God can replace those boys, I’d like to replace the machines.’
Garfield Weston
This shows a total trust from a donor that we don’t always see – a complete trust that you will use the money you need for the purposes they want.
How did Lord Beaverbrook react?
He burst into tears. (who has had a gift so generous, or kind, that they have shed a little tear?)
Fundraising is, and continues to be emotional work, and we are emotionally invested in raising funds for the causes we support.
So what happened next…
First secure the gift.
Max Beaverbrook wrote in £100,000 in the cheque.
As good fundraisers know you should not waste an opportunity.
Lord Beaverbrook asked for permission to publicise the gift. Garfield Weston was reluctant and wanted the donation to remain private. But Lord Beaverbrook said “between you and me … there’s too [much] power behind this” and that if the gift was made public it would help raise over £1m. This incentive to do more good was too much to resist and so the story of this generous donation appeared in the papers (the Daily Mail mentions Garfield Weston’s ‘piercing blue eyes’).
Keeping up with the Joneses
The lead gift from Garfield Weston inspired J W McConnell another Canadian businessman to give $1m to buy a whole squadron.
We often use the inspiration of a lead gift to launch a campaign and inspire others to give.
Major philanthropists want to be seen to be supporting good causes and publicising gifts creates a powerful social norm about what your peers are doing – so publicity can help and inspire others.
We saw similar behaviour after the Notre Dame fire. When one major donation was quickly followed by another – but as well as the big mega gifts our attention was also drawn to the smaller and more personal gifts. The two images below capture these extremes the 200 million and the 9 year old sending in her picket money. We tend to focus at both extremes of the gift spectrum. But like Notre Dame with spitfire campaigns – it was the big gifts and the small but mighty ones that attracted the attention.
Shopping list
So the promote the campaign, Lord Beaverbrook put together a price list of various engines needed but the Spitfire caught the imagination. On his list each Spitfire cost £5,000.
Now this was a made up number, the true cost was just over £12,000. So maybe not the most ethical approach.
This shopping list enabled every one to ‘do their bit’
A Merlin engine costs £2,000
Gun was £100
Spark plugs cost 8 shillings
60 screws cost 5 shillings
Rivet was sixpence
Why and how does this work?
When faced with a big target – financial or aspirational in changing the world (£10m or 2million starving children) donors can often worry that there small contribution is just a drop in the bucket and not going to make a tangible different to the cause. By breaking the total down into manageable chunks every person can see how their 8 shillings or sixpence is going to help and make a difference.
It reduces the cognitive load if we can see how one small – and real number makes the difference. And the realness and specificity of the number adds to our belief that it is a real number (we can sometimes mistrust a nice round number and have more belief that a mosquito net costs £5.20 rather than a round £5).
They can then exercise their moral imagination and see like this boy their gift in action….
Is that my rear tyre wheel mummy?
Every time one boy saw a spitfire he asked ‘Is that my rear wheel tyre?’ as he had donated his pocket money to the spitfire fund, and received a thank you from Buckingham Palace saying he had raised enough for the rear tyre.
Spitfires were constantly flying overhead so their personal donation remained salient and they were constantly reminded of the impact that they had. And to imagine that Spitfire was the one that they had contributed to. We often ask our supporters to imagine what their gift has done, but in this case they could see daily the planes in the air.
When you donate blood you get a text message after the donation to tell you where the donation has gone, with a map showing you where it is and in which hospital and that it has been used.
This is what happened to my blood after it was donated:
Isn’t that amazing? And a really powerful way to show donor’s the impact of what their gift is doing. What is the equivalent for your charity?
Receiving feedback like this floods our brain with happy reward chemicals.
As well as seeing the tangible impact of the donations we make, we like to see the progress we are making towards a goal – this is called the endowed progress effect.
This endowed progress effect is often employed in the famous fundraising thermometer. A device used by Mayor of Islington in August 1940. He sat opposite the Nag’s Head pub raising money (only interrupted for lunch and an air raid warning) with a giant thermometer marking progress hour by hour– he eventually raised £2,500 for spitfires.
In Market Lavington – a village in Wiltshire – they created an outline of a Spitfire in the square and challenged the villagers to fill it with coins.
This image of a spitfire was created at the Green Dragon on 1941
Now we know that this uses something called the endowed progress effect.
You want some donors lined up at the start of the campaign to start donating, creating a powerful social norm, creating a bandwagon effect and showing that this is normal and anchoring people in what a normal gift looks like – if everyone is giving 6d, you will give 6d too but if others are giving two shillings you will follow suit. As we want to see our progress rewarded you would expect that the speed of donations would also increase as they near completion and people might be fighting over who gets to put that final coin down and complete the mission. Completing things is satisfying and proximity to success is motivational, as an individual realises they can make something happen.
Messengers like you
For some an authority messenger like Garfield Weston can be attractive and inspiring, but for others it can be off putting – it can make us react and say ‘well its fine for a millionaire entrepreneur to give but people like me can’t afford to’
However in this campaign they understood the power of likeable messengers who people could identify with. Donations came pouring in with testimonial messages of support such as:
“From all at No.15 Station Lane”,
“My week’s pocket money – Fred Smith aged 7″, “
“My first week’s old age pension – 10 shillings towards our Spitfire”.
Like all good fundraisers we know that testimony from real life donors helps create a powerful social norm showing other people like you are giving. This range of quotes from local areas, from children and pensioners enable people to identify with people like them.
So whether your regional identity, your gender, your employment status, your age was how you identified there was a messenger for you.
Now this might seem common sense to you and I think is one of the special things about looking into fundraising history – we see things that we instinctively know work as fundraisers, as humans interact with humans, about how we communicate – and in recent years we have the science to back that up – that might be academic papers, it might be fMRI scanners literally seeing what is happening inside our brains in certain conditions or often with lab tests with university students being studied for prosocial behaviour. This example comes from academic research and shows the real power of social norms when ‘people like me’ are used – generosity increases as the other people are identified as being nearer you – university students in Sweden are more generous than just other people, but university students from your university encourages even bigger donations.
All of these academic and other studies confirm what we know about the philanthropic psychology and human behaviour that the old wisdom from the past instinctively knew. But now we know it we can apply it rigorously and target the interventions we know work to help provide more ways to offer people ways to help change the world.
Name Letter effect
Have you ever heard your name spoken through the noise of a crowded pub or party?
In behavioural science the ‘cocktail party effect’ is essentially selective attention. At a cocktail party or any loud social setting, we can hear our own name amongst the hubbub – we are the most important to ourselves and we pay attention to things that resonate with our sense of self.
This draws on a deep identity connection to our own name. Ever since we were born our neurons have been trained to react and fire together when they hear our own name (or names similar to our own).
So as a Dorothy you are wired to hear and pay attention to Dorothy.
And a Canadian Dorothy used the power of her name to fundraise …
Dorothy wanted to raise funds to support the Spitfire fund, so she sold some of her evening gowns to raise money. She printed cards that said
Is your name Dorothy? If so, rally around and help buy a Spitfire for Britain.
She and her friends posted them to every Dorothy they knew and themed their fundraising around Dorothys
20,000 tea parties all hosted by someone called Dorothy
All Dorothy musical evenings
Auction of actor Dorothy Lamour’s sarong
This created momentum and they took advantage of the bandwagon and excitement to get more Dorothy’s involved – t this spread across to US with the “Vancouver chapter of the Canadian Dorothy Spitfire Fund is seeking noted Dorothys of the United States,”
“Dorothys Plan Galloping Teas,” – 25 women called Dorothy invited friends to tea charging 25 cents each – and like a chain letter they passed it onto other Dorothys of their acquaintance.
Dorothy Thompson, journalist and broadcaster donated a copy of her radio talk
Dorothy Parker was invited to write a poem
This global appeal successfully raised the funds and they bought a Spitfire which was named for the Dorothys that raised the money and called Dorothy of Great Britain and Empire .
But why does this work?
In 2008, data from seven emergency hurricane appeals were examined including Hurricanes Katrina, Mitch and Rita. Researchers Chandler, Griffin, and Sorensen found donors who shared an initial with the hurricane were overrepresented in the donors. So donors beginning with ‘K’ were 31% more likely to have given to support Hurricane Katrina relief in the 6 months after the hurricane.
‘M’ named people made up 30% more of the donor population during the two months period after Mitch devastated Honduras and Nicaragua in 1998.
Sharing the same first name or letter has also been shown to help donors identify more with fundraisers (Burger, Messian, Patel, del Prado& Anderson, 2004 and Bekkers, 2010 in an article entitled ‘George gives to geology Jane’)
A lab experiment showed a request to give to a child in need resulted in 61% giving but adding the name, age and a picture increased giving rates to 90% (Kogut, Ritow, 2005)
Learning the fundraisers’ name increased the average gift size by 50% (Bohnet and Frey, 1999) For alumni fundraisers donors were more likely to give when their first name was similar to the name of the university.
Knowing someone’s name builds a connection, a relationship, when we know the name – the name of the beneficiary – even the name of the fundraiser we are more likely to give (people give to people!)
So Canadian Dorothy knew that innate and personal connection to a name as a rallying call to donate. (This is one of the reasons why decision science is fascinating – we know these things work, we have seen them used, maybe unconsciously used them ourselves, but as our understanding of the science develops we can prove they work, and test how they work and see what is happening inside our brains as these things work)
Naming Rights
Which brings me onto naming rights. One of the components of the campaign was the joy of raising the funds was naming the Spitfire.
Now when people are not just naming it for themselves and have a little creative freedom we can see some interesting names – Boaty McBoatface being a prime example, and the Greenpeace whale Mr Splashy Pants spring to mind (as well as the names of all the Scottish Gritters) And Spitfire names were no different. Some were conventionally named for the country that funded them such as Trinidad, or Hong Kong or Sheffield.
However, a sense humour was demonstrated in the naming of the planes
The Kennel Club named theirs the Dog Fighter
The ABC cinema chain named them– Miss ABCs (there were 3 bought)
Marks & Spencer named theirs ‘The Marksmen’ following in store collection
Woolworths named theirs Nix Six Primus (which referred to their pre-war policy of keeping all prices below sixpence – don’t waste a marketing opportunity to get your corporate message into a naming opportunity!)
Some were more traditionally named. One anonymous donor named a plane Heather for his daughter.
Interestingly the RAF faced a challenge similar to fundraisers today, with donors and their naming rights demands. There was a designated space on the plane where a name ought to go (9 inches by six inches) but donors wanted their names in all sorts of shapes, font and sizes even including coats of arms!
When planes were completed donors got a photograph and a certificate acknowledging their support and so they could see their plane. These were again used for publicity and to generate further funds.
Merch
Another important identity marker can be in self branding and wearing merchandise that aligns with the band, the cause or marks you out as you.
As part of the campaign an important visual symbol of your support of your local Spitfire fund was getting the badge. Some of these were your standard pin badge but many were shaped like spitfires and some were even made from the Perspex used in the windows of the planes. There were also bracelets made.
In certain towns and villages this became like not wearing a poppy on Remembrance Sunday – it would have been unpatriotic not to be seen to be supporting.
Strange how potent cheap music is
And what better than combining the power of the local identity with another powerful tool – the power of music, and rhyme.
The Spitfire Song was written as a fundraising song and it was customisable so you could add your local area name into the song e.g. Hampshire or Bournemouth
Again the importance of geography and local identity in fundraising
‘We’ll make one of their number, write our name upon the wing
When the planes are flying over, you will hear old Britain sing”
A Spitfire a Day keeps the Nazis Away – the Rhyme is the reason
The slogan of the Islington Spitfire Club was ‘each bob you pay keeps the bomber away.’
Or acrostic poems were made
Give All you can Invest in the Fight Vanquish ‘that man’ End Europe’s Dark Night
Why is that important? because we now know that we find messages more persuasive and more memorable when they rhyme and more accurate.
Using rhymes in campaigns can make them more memorable.
Creative and local fundraising
There was no centralised campaign and each community or group was empowered to fundraise and donate in ways that suited them.
We have already seen some creative examples, here are a few more … what links all of these that the methods are really linked to spitfires and the war
Penny on the red – every time the air raid siren sounded every member of the club had to donate a penny to the Shoreham Spitfire Club
6 pence was charged to view a crashed German plane in Kent to raise funds for Spitfires and in Dudley they charged sixpence to have a look at a Messerschmitt – band leader Henry Hall bought his band and they played They’ll Always Be an England and a dog called Jerry climbed on the wreck
A Mrs Clark charged a penny to see a deactivated mine and raised over £9 from 2000 visitors to it
In a London cinema, during an air raid, the manager of a cinema pushed a wheelbarrow up and down the aisle saying “the more you give, the less raids there will be” as he solicited donations.
10 a penny club – for every ten aircraft you had to donate penny – the fishmonger in Stevenage had a chalk board outside the shop to mark off shot down planes – they raised £454 in the first 5 days
Madeline and Nanette Drayton painted 12 large posters of Spitfires and people filled them with coins – raising £3750
The campaign ultimately raised £13m.
What fundraising lessons are there from this Spitfire Fund campaign?
React quickly to current events
Keep the story in the news
Make it easy for donors to see their impact – chunk the campaign into small and manageable achievable goals that they can help achieve
You don’t have to do all the work – empower people to raise funds and have fun and be creatively
Use the identities that donors have – to their village, their town, to their employment status, age, gender to help connect and establish a powerful norm
This is a reduced version of a talk given at Fundraising Summer School in Dublin, May 2024.
https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/blank.jpg7211280adminhttps://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.pngadmin2024-05-16 09:56:452024-06-06 19:50:53How a blank cheque sparked a fundraising revolution?
After watching Nye at the National Theatre and reading the play, I have been reflecting on the importance of philanthropy and fundraising to fund healthcare before the NHS was introduced in 1948 in the UK (and of course it has remained fundamental, but this article focuses on pre 1948 examples).
Playtext of ‘Nye’
Aneurin Bevan, known as Nye said he wanted to ‘replace the patchwork quilt of local philanthropies’ with a nationalised health service.
In the play he says:
“The health service is a complete mess, it is impossible to navigate and grossly unfair. The voluntary hospitals serve the rich, and the council hospitals serve the poor. The wealthy cities have all the facilities and all the specialists. And poor regions are stuck with Victorian hospitals falling apart”
Nye was inspired by the Tredegear Medical Aid Society where (quoting Nye in the play)
“All miners pay into it every week. And it covers the cost of six doctors and six nurses who take care of the whole town … The Tredegear Medical Aid Society covesr not only those who pay into it but those that don’t. Women, children, the elderly. .. And it works.
The mutual aid model of the Medical Aid Society was a well established one, and Nye wanted to ‘Tregegarise’ the whole country so everyone got the same health service
What was that patchwork quilt of philanthropies like?
To describe the provision of healthcare as patchwork is a very apt. The provision of healthcare relied on local patronage and campaigns, an inspired local leader, guild, monastery, legacy or philanthropist.
Here are just a few of the pre-NHS patches of how fundraising and philanthropy enabled healthcare and hospitals.
In the Bible, in the Last Judgement parable of the sheep and the goats in Matthew 25, Jesus says
Come, ye blessed of my Father, inherit the kingdom prepared for you from the foundation of the world: For I was an hungred, and ye gave me meat: I was thirsty, and ye gave me drink: I was a stranger, and ye took me in: Naked, and ye clothed me: I was sick, and ye visited me: I was in prison, and ye came unto me. Then shall the righteous answer him, saying, Lord, when saw we thee an hungred, and fed thee? or thirsty, and gave thee drink? When saw we thee a stranger, and took thee in? or naked, and clothed thee? Or when saw we thee sick, or in prison, and came unto thee? And the King shall answer and say unto them, Verily I say unto you, Inasmuch as ye have done it unto one of the least of these my brethren, ye have done it unto me.
Matthew 25, King James Bible
Caring for the sick in hospital and supporting hospitals was one of the corporal works of mercy and in Christianity, and in other faiths, a way of living out your faith. So churches, monasteries and religious communities frequently administered and raised funds for hospitals – you can read more about how here although it is frequently through an extrapolation of the existence of hospitals that we can see that some sort of organised fundraising must have been in action.
Stained glass window from Freiburg Minster, c1230 showing the six Corporal Works of Mercy
The first hospital founded by subscriptions was in 1719. Banker ‘Good Henry’ Hoare, also know as Henry the Magnificent made a donation of £10 and with three friends they founded the Westminster Hospital with the aim to ‘provide poor sick people…with necessary food and physic during illness‘.
Selling sensational novels to raise funds was another way in which money was raised to support the work of hospitals. The Magdelen – History of the First Penitent Prostitute Received Into that Charitable Asylum. With Anecdotes of Other Penitents by the Rev. William Dodd was one such novel. It told, in letter form, the story of a young woman who was seduced by an inappropriate suitor, ended up pregnant and in care of the Magdalen hospital as part of her rehabilitation. These novels were very popular both for their salacious stories, as well as, raising the money needed to run the hospitals.
The appeal to raise the funds for the Foundling Hospital by Sir Thomas Coram took 17 years, beginning in 1728. Thomas Coram returned from his sea merchant career and was appalled by the number of children abandoned (known as foundlings) and wanted to provide for them with a new Foundling Hospital. Celebrity and well connected patrons were essential to the success and achieving his ambitions and the necessary funds. He enlisted William Hogarth the famous painter to be a Governor of the charity and he (and his celebrity painting friends – Reynolds and Gainsborough) donated paintings to be sold for the good of the hospital establishing an art gallery on site. Composer Handel also supported the Hospital with his Foundling Hospital Anthem which concludes with his famous Messiah and Hallelujah Chorus which raised over £7,000 for the hospital (there is a suggestion that ending this reflection on charitable giving with the Chorus links back to Matthew 25 and the parable of the sheep and the goats). Handel also donated an organ to the hospital which was repeatedly used for fundraising concerts. Coram is often credited with being one of the first fundraisers, but as we have been discovering there were paid and professional fundraisers much earlier. More Coram and the campaign for the Foundling Hospital here. Raising funds for the hospital’s continuing operation was an ongoing task and so public parades and public examinations of poor children such as the children from the Foundling Hospital were common place. They were used as a way to solicit contributions, thank donors and demonstrate the impact of the gifts in rehabilitating and training children (show don’t tell!) Attending Sunday lunch at the Foundling Hospital was a fashionable Sunday outing.
An invitation to examine the charity childrenSunday lunch at the Foundling Hospital with donors watching
In Birmingham in 1860s, it took just five days for Thomas Heslop’s campaign to raise the funds needed to create the Birmingham and Midlands Free Hospital for Sick Children. This shows a clear appetitive from the general public to support hospitals and the care of the sick.
May Seacole financed herself to go to the Crimean War to assist the soldiers, running her British Hotel caring for those that could afford to pay. She was the first woman to enter Sevastopol and was praised by Lord Rokesby for her bravery. When the war finished she was left nearly bankrupt with stock, and campaigns were held to support her (by The Times and Punch). A four day festival at the Royal Albert Hall attended by over 40,000 people was so badly organised that she barely received any of the proceeds – as captured in this Horrible Histories clip
#fundraisingfail Mary Seacole returned from the Crimea & was declared bankrupt – a 4 day fundraising gala Seacole Fund Grand Mimitary Festival attended by over 40,000 people raised only £57 because of poor organisation via Horrible Histories #fundraisinghistorypic.twitter.com/gs1YO33DJx
Famous singer Jenny Lind helped raise the funds for the England’s second children’s hospital in Norwich. The Norwich Hospital was the 17th established in England in 1772 (after first being proposed in 1758) and raised funds through subscriptions and fundraising sermons at the cathedral as was common at the time. As part of her world tour, Jenny Lind visited Norwich in 1847 for two sell out concerts. She stayed with the Bishop of Norwich at the cathedral. She was performing at St Andrew Hall and added a third concert especially so that the poor of the city could attend. She developed a strong relationship with the Bishop’s family and Katherine, the bishop’s wife, became godmother to Jenny Lind’s daughter. In 1849, Jenny Lind returned to the city and raised £1,253 for the poor of the city with a concert. But this was raised with no specific purpose in mind, and the city had to decide what to do with it. One suggestion, from Jenny Lind herself, was to stand in the marketplace and throw the money to the poor (certainly a novel way to distribute charity!) However, whilst they were deciding what the funds should do Great Ormond Street Hospital was founded in 1852, and the idea of a children’s hospital in Norwich was mooted. In 1853 this was unanimously endorsed at a public meeting. The funds that the Jenny Lind concert had raised were used to purchase the two houses that would form the hospital. The hospital was known locally as The Jenny.
Jenny Lind at the Jenny
1859 the Kings Hospital Fund introduced Hospital Shopping Days in London on a Tuesday in November when shops and cabs had to show poster and give a % of that day’s profits to charity. The first day raised £1,027 but was not repeated as the tradespeople felt that the Hospital Shopping Day was a levy imposed on them – a reminder that those involved in fundraising must feel is there choice about how they are supporting – philanthropy is often defined as ‘voluntary action for the public good’ (Michael Moody) – so extrapolating from that fundraising must be a voluntary choice about how to support the public good rather than a tax imposed!
Like the relic quests above, there were designated days for raising funds for certain causes and hospitals were often the recipients. In 1912 Liverpool League of Welldoers raised funds for the Hospital Saturday Fund by a ‘travelling Christmas tree’ on cart with presents and collection boxes.
Author Thomas Hardy made a rare guest appearance at the fundraising fair for the Dorset County Hospital in 1921 – the fair included processions, bands, a “Money Trail”, stalls, dancing in the evening and a Japanese daylight firework display. This fair raised 20% of the revenue needed for the hospital that year showing how important and necessary fundraising was https://historydch.com/news/archive2014/
The leaflet issued to all British homes about the advent of the National Health service clearly stated:
“But it is not a “charity”. You are paying all paying for it, mainly as taxpayers, and it will relieve your money worries in times of illness”
The above examples are just a few ways in which healthcare was fundraised for and enacted pre 1948. There is much more research to be done on how funds were raised and organised for healthcare – pre and post the introduction of the NHS.
End of ‘Nye’ at the National Theatre
https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2024/03/IMG_0639-scaled.jpeg25601713adminhttps://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.pngadmin2024-03-28 22:15:592024-03-28 22:16:00Pathwork quilt of local philanthropies
In the last few years gamification has been highlighted as a way to increase engagement with supporters – making charitable engagement more fun, and driving loyalty and community.
But it is not new in fundraising.
Competition and gaming elements can be seen in cathedral building in the thirteenth century – with areas of the city competing against each other to raise the most money (Pavia Gate vs Porta Nuevo Gate https://marinajones.uk/butter/).
But have you ever been asked to ‘winkle up’?
This is a particular request made by members of the Winkle Club in Hastings
Founded in the Prince Albert pub in Hastings in 1900 by local fisherman wanting to do something for poor local families and provide a special Christmas feast.
Each member is given a winkle shell (an edible sea snail – with snail removed and filled with wax) which must be produced if challenged to ‘winkle-up’ by a fellow member. If they cannot produce their winkle they are fined (originally 1 penny but now £1). The challenger must report the winkle up challenge before the week is out or pay a double fine!
They have become a local institution, in 1908
A hundred hungry men were served with dinner in the Harbour Shed, decorated with bunting, on Tuesday (31 Dec), while an estimated 750 children were given a good square meal dinner on Wednesday”.
Hastings Mail
Members of the Winkle Club preparing for the annual Christmas party 1948
Pubs seem to be a fruitful place for the founding of charities as Howard Lake recently commented.
Additional fines and penalties were imposed, but all for fun, including
It is frequently easy to induce a member to ‘go over and Winkle Up old so-and-so there in the corner for a lark’, only to find that old-so-and-so is not a member. Another fine. All’s fair in Winkling-up and it all goes to charity
The Club’s rule also cite:
A favourite trick is for one member to say to another: “Put your winkle on the table for a moment; I should like to compare it with mine for colour” – or size or any other excuse. If the other fellow in a thoughtless moment puts his winkle down, he at once becomes liable for a fine. Moreover, no member may ever have two winkles in his possession. Another artful dodge is casually to invite a member to pick up and examine a second winkle with some appropriate remark – “Have you ever seen one like that?” or something of the sort. If he unthinkingly takes it, he is at once in trouble and a fine is duly levied“
The Winkle King
In the 1960s, Slogger Hoad was the Winkle King of Hastings and had special suit made out of 9,626 winkles which took six months to make (and can be seen at the Hastings Fisherman Museum)
Imitation is the sincerest form of flattery
The Winkle Club originally got the idea from the Hasting Acorn Club. This Club formed in the Royal Oak pub and has an acorn as their symbol, but the fisherman of the Prince Albert wanted something that reflected their fishing tradition so chose the winkle.
Cute local custom, yes, but also some fundraising lessons
So what can we learn from this local custom
Make donating fun – can you add gamification so that there is a fun and competitive element to your campaigns? The tricks that Winklers tried to play on each other to catch each other out and make more money aided the campaign. This can incentivise people to be involved in campaigns but also creates a sense of community which helps build loyalty. The fun element adds an extra dopamine happy chemical hit to their giving experience.
Your identity as a Winkler is important and a shared local one – recognising other supporters like you is important – whether it is asking someone to ‘winkle up’ or seeing a supporter has the tote bag or a badge identifying them as another supporter. We like to have ways to identify our support and have social proof of what others like us do.
Celebrity winklers – having famous members helps promote your cause. Famous Winkle Club members include the late Queen, the Queen Mother, Norman Wisdom, Admiral Montgomery and Winston Churchill.
Adapt your offer to target segments of your supporters – Winston Churchill was presented with a special gold monogrammed winkle as an honorary member (see below) and the Queen was given a gold winkle made into a broach form. How can you treat special members differently to honour and recognise their status?
News stories – make the most of getting press stories about ‘winkle up’ challenges especially from your famous members.
In 1953 at the dress rehearsal for the coronation Field Marshal Montgomery charged the Mayor of Dover to ‘winkle up’ – the mayor having been to several functions that day did not have his winkle in that pair of trousers and had to pay a fine (reported in the Hastings & St. Leonards Observer 6 June 1953 Pg. 0007)
In 2008, Admiral Boyce was answering questions at a government committee when an MP asked one final question – did he have his winkle with him? The Admiral did not so paid the fine – but the MP who asked the question – Hastings MP Michael Foster did not have his either so was also fined (there was also a light hearted debate about whether he ought to have been challenged when at work!) See curiosities here https://winkleclub.org/curiosities/
Rewards – both the current opportunities to donate that I saw to donate to the Winkle Club on a recent trip to Hastings are fun. Wishing wells and a giant winkle shell that makes a noise when you donate. Make your donation boxes fun, interactive and engaging.
Rhyme as the reason effect -using rhyming messages can make them more memorable.
Building, maintaining and rebuilding cathedrals and monasteries was an expensive and ongoing business.
Here are just some of the ways in which funds were raised from the tenth century to the fifteenth. Many of which we see today in various forms for capital campaigns, or other appeals, and others we can adapt.
Eat Butter
What have you given up for Lent?
If you had permission to break that in exchange for a donation would you?
During Lent, the faithful were to abstain from meats, dairy and eggs, which mean that the townspeople of Rouen could not enjoy Normandy butter. However, if they made a donation of 6 deniers Tournais to Archbishop Robert de Criosmare’s fabric fund for the cathedral they would be let off their Lenten discipline and permitted to eat butter.
The fundraising by this exemption was so successful that it raised enough money for the tower of the cathedral – which is known to this day as the Tour de Beurre (Butter Tower) because of where the funds come from (and that is made of local yellow limestone that has a buttery hue!)
Butter Tower at Roeun
Sponsor a window, a pillar, a figure, a chapel, a candle, an arch, a day’s labour, a year’s labour
Basically you can sponsor anything.
We like to be able to know what our contribution did – to say to others or just to ourselves ‘I did that’. The options within cathedral buildings were endless – arches, windows, chapels, figures on a portal (at Notre Dame they originally planned to have 28 chapels but the popularity of chapel support locally meant they had over 50 chapels were installed – how’s that for donor dominance!).
Windows proved to be one of the most popular ways that individuals or local trades could show their support and the sponsor is often shown in the window – so we see windows from fishmongers, clothshearers, leather dresses, masons and church builders.
Shoemakers guild contribution celebrated in stained glass at Chartres
(Although, the cathedral in Tournai complained about the ‘pompous trimmings’ of the excessive donor led art projects that supported additional decoration rather than the building of the cathedral – donor dominance even then!)
It was not just physical capital items that were supported. People also made donations to fund positions – for a day, for a week, for a year. Again demonstrating that every contribution can be attributed to part of the project. It is easier for our brains to process and understand – 3s pays for one day’s labour than to grasp the complexity and cost of a whole building project.
Nowadays capital campaigns allow people to do everything from name a building or a room, but also the smaller and more tangible items from a light switch to a toilet brush, well as supporting the salaries of posts.
And the church were creative and offered lots of opportunities to credit donors – from donor books, coats of arms on walls, pictures in painting and windows and many more. In Strasbourg each week they held an elaborate ceremony on Sunday after the high mass reading out the names of the donors to the fabric fund and writing their name in the Liber Donoatiorium (donation book) For more about donor recognition in churches see this earlier blog about donor recognition or the IWITOT (I wish I thought of that session) about donor recognition on SOFII’s website.
Although as well as crediting donors, these memorials could be used to name and shame. In the donor book of Milan it lists that ‘all the braiders of Milan except Giorgio Coiro‘. So poor Giorgio is forever immortalised as the one that did not pay (maybe don’t try this with your donors!)
Donating money to have the bells rung for the living or the dead could also grant you an indulgence. Indulgences could be offered, reducing the amount of time the donor spent in purgatory, and hence placing them nearer to heaven. But it was a core thing that needed to happen and be paid for – a great way of funding those core costs.
How can we chunk our campaigns into chunks so that people can know that they have supported a specific thing to happen?
How can we recognise and celebrate those gifts in creative and aligned ways?
Gamification and competition
In Milan in the 1380s what galvanised the capital campaign for the cathedral was some healthy local competition. One local neighbourhood, the Porta Nuova gate started a weekly collection. The next week the Pavia Gate started, with the aim of being seen more generous than their neigbours. And the competition spread.
How can you introduce fun and friendly competition into your campaign?
Tap into supporter identity
Milan Cathedral
The competition between the Pavia Gate and the Port Nuova above highlights the importance of hyper local identity.
Every supporter has several identities that reflect who they are (or how they want to be seen as their ideal version of themselves) your fundraiser message can connect with these identities – as a Christian, as a Catholic, as a proud city resident. But identities go deeper and hyper local. In Milan there are dedications and donations from ‘the young men of the East Gate‘ – this is not just an affinity to the city, or to the cathedral, or saint, but to the local area –
Where are the identity triggers with your donors? How do you provide segments that reflect true and deep connections?
Calendar highlights
Church campaigns used high days and special holy days to enhance campaigns. For example, Assumption-tide was used as a way to galvanise campaigns. The relic quests (which you read more about here) often worked between Pentecost to Assumption (partly because of the weather).
Most religions have seasons when charitable giving is particularly encouraged like Ramadan or Lent, that can be used as times to encourage giving. Or anniversaries (of your founding, of a specific event) can be used as a hook for a campaign.
How can you use dates and moments in the year to bring life to your campaign?
Be organised
Milan cathedral had an organising committee of 12 nobles, 9 canons, 16 citizens and 3 lawyers (and 20 notaries were busy copying out the bishops letters to diocesan clergy requesting support). One hundred local citizens also oversaw the work being done checking the quality of materials and work being done. Fundraising is not a lone task of the fundraiser working away on their own or with their team it needs the whole organisation to be involved in supporting success. It also requires planning and strategy.
Milan was built relatively quickly there are other examples when fundraising stalled because of plague, war, the Crusades or other political upheavals. The most successful campaigns had a visionary champion who believed in the project and excited others and got them organised.
The Canterbury register of donors opened 8 years before the building began!
Have the structures and processes in place – budgets, targets, ROIs, LTVs are important and you need the staff infrastructure to support success.
Who are your champions that can excite your supporters and your staff?
Gifts in kind
As well as financial donations, gifts in kinds of bricks and stones from other were also welcomed.
“If I were a shepherd I would bring a lamb” (from the carol In the Bleak Midwinter)
Devotional gifts also included a horse, a basket of cherries and an egg.
How can you encourage gifts in kind of the things you need?
Authority figures
In 1171 the Bishop of Norwich sat on the cathedral entrance to accept donations from the faithful. We are influenced by the messengers that ask for gifts, but also get an extra warm glow from making the donation to someone important.
Leadership gifts
In a capital campaign you always want a leadership gift – a big gift from a significant person – with authority and integrity to lead the way for others to support. Often in the Middle Ages this would be the Bishop or the Cathedral chapter.
Going once, going twice ….
People donated and bequeathed items to the fabric funds and these were put up for public auction to raise funds. These included gowns, boots, towels. jewellery, furs, daggers, helmets, gauntlets, and silver slippers. These seem to have been sold at a commercial rate rather thank like an auction generating over the odds prices as a way to support the charity.
Employee involvement and the Ikea effect
The challenge for fundraisers can be finding an appropriate and useful way for partners to be involved in your project – it can be painting, gardening, volunteering at an event but it tends to be an important way that the employer can demonstrate their impact and charity credentials and build teams.
This was not a problem for our medieval counterparts, as using free labour was part and parcel of building a cathedral. Various guilds and confraternities would come and offer free labour for a day or a week.
As well as burly people to get the job done, this also has an added effect of creating a deeper senses of engagement and commitment to the cause. The Ikea effect means we value something more if we have been involved in its creation (like the flat pack furniture) – the involvement of the armourers or the drapers had a vested interest in the success and use of the cathedral by donating their time to building it.
How can you get people involved in the cause to make them feel more involved? They may not be able to dig a foundation but how can they feel connected to making things happen?
Donation boxes
Donation boxes are nothing new and recorded in the Temple in Jerusalem in the time of Jesus.
In Milan in the fourteenth century, a donation box was placed next to the work building the cathedral encouraging more donations.
There is always an argument about how effective they are for actually gathering donations, or whether they are more useful for the mere exposure effect of the need (and there is more about their power and persuadability here). Perhaps they were particularly effective on relic tours, when after an emotive sermon two trusted men would solicit donations.
In memory giving
Giving in memory of someone we love can elicit a bigger and more emotional gift. In Milan we see some early in memory giving for ‘by Francischino Carcano for the soul of Sempliciano Limit who formally resided with him‘.
How can we use the emotions we feel for other people (dead or alive) to inspire gifts?
Anonymity offered
Not all donors want their name, their guild or their crest displayed it is important to be able to offer donors the choice to be anonymous – this example from Milan ‘offered on the high altar by a certain illustrious and exalted lady who would not be named’
It is always a good option to allow your donor’s the choice to remain anonymous.
(But sometimes anonymous can be an excuse for even more credit and this clip from Curb Your Enthusiasm about anonymous donations)
Location, location, location
Toulouse Cathedral made use of its location on the route to the St James of Compostela pilgrimage route so its donation boxes did particularly well.
Use the power of celebrity
When Pope Innocent IV stayed in Lyon 1245-51, the lagging cathedral fabric fund had a huge boost. Using the power of celebrity can help increase donations to the campaign – with the pope you have a celebrity and an authority linked to your cause.
Make the most of bad things happening
Archbishop Richard le Scrope was executed in 1405 for his part in the Northern Uprisings. Pope Innocent VII excommunicated those that had been involved in his trial. He was buried at York and viewed as a saint and martyr by some. York had been lacking a saint, and the veneration of Scrope’s relics increased revenues and donations.
(As an aside – he is one of the traitors, along with Westmoreland, in Shakespeare’s Henry IV Part Two – where he is definitely a traitor not a saint)
Myth making and reality
There is an enduring myth that Henry II built Poitiers cathedral. He is depicted with his wife and children in the central Crucifixion window. In reality it was a much more communal effort with his contribution, the bishop, the chapter, other parishes, burghers and local craftspeople. After capital campaigns, certain myths develop about how it was funded and by who.
Questions over whether you can accept money from Prostitutes of Paris
Having a policy and concern for repetitional risk in accepting donations is nothing new – generally the church disapproved of usury (taking interest) but the clerics of Notre Dame had some interesting discussions about whether to accept donations from the guild of prostitutes – read more on concerns about tainted money below:
Make sure you know who you will accept money from, and a have a plan on how you assess their suitability
Get drunk
From the tenth century at least the use of church ales was common place to help raise much needed funds. These were social occasions with much beer, dancing and games. Parishioners allocated members of the parish to brew the beer which was sold at a premium to raise funds. These ales were also used for raising support for members of the parish who had fallen on hard times and were a form of horizontal philanthropy and mutual aid. These ales were also used to help newly married couples – which is where the word ‘bridal’ (bride-ale) comes from.
Although this practice as open to abuse and sometimes people just got drunk and claimed it was ‘for charity’.
Social fundraising like gala dinners and balls continue to be a tried and tested way to raise funds with people paying over the odds/commercial rate to support a charity and/or enjoy the social time.
Make fundraising fun and social and create events where people can come together to support you
And some practices that we will not be adopting
Confiscating property of heretics and those of other faiths (especially Jews)
Enforced taxes and tithes and contributions from other parishes
Using the confessional (in Strasbourg) to stress the importance of donation
Priest needed to be at the drawing up of wills so the importance of gifts for salvation could be stressed (in Toulouse in the thirteenth century). In Strasbourg in 1283, the city stopped all bequests to the church because of the undue pressure put on the dying and the protestations by heirs.
Arresting donors that don’t pay up – Michel de Lucy (son of the King and Archbishop of Bourges) was compelled to pay to restore the cathedral by his father the king. When he did not pay, he was arrested in Paris and forced to pay.
In St Luke’s Gospel it says “for which of you desiring to build a tower, does not first sit down and count the cost, whether he has enough to complete it” – words not taken on board by many medieval cathedral builders!
In 1544, Emperor Charles V wanted to donate a new rose window to Utrecht cathedral but they had to refuse as they could not afford the installation costs.
So what can we learn from medieval cathedral building schemes
How can you get people involved in the cause to make them feel more involved? They may not be able to dig a foundation but how can they feel connected to making things happen?
How can we chunk our campaigns into chunks so that people can know that they have supported a specific thing to happen?
How can we recognise and celebrate those gifts in creative and aligned ways?
How can you use dates and moments in the year to bring life to your campaign?
Where are the identity triggers with your donors? How do you provide segments that reflect true and deep connections?
How can you encourage gifts in kind of the things you need?
Who is receiving the gifts?
How can we use the emotions we feel for other people (dead or alive) to inspire gifts?
Make sure you know who you will accept money from, and a have a plan on how you assess their suitability
Make fundraising fun and social and create events where people can come together to support you
Who are your champions that can excite your supporters and your staff?
References
‘How a Cathedral was Built in the fourteenth century’ by E Bishop (1898)
‘Two thousand years of disreputable history’ by Redmond Mullins
‘Gold Was the Mortar The Economics of Cathedral Building’ by Henry Kraus
‘Conviviality and Charity in Medieval and Early Modern England’ Judith M Bennett Past and Present 1992
‘Financing Catherdral Building in the Middle Ages the Generosity of the Faithful’ by Wim Vroom
https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/04/shoemakers.jpg280602adminhttps://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.pngadmin2024-03-15 21:09:482025-09-07 13:56:48Eat butter & get drunk: How to raise money for a cathedral
1. Challenge events – raise a minimum to participate
You may have thought that raising £5,000 to walk the Great Wall of China or bungee jump off a bridge were newer inventions but it is something fundraisers have done for over a hundred years.
In 1902 the Young Helpers League of the Salvation Army had to fundraise and then present a purse with a minimum donation to attend an event at the Royal Albert Hall.
2. Mircodonations before microdonations were a thing
‘Grace before meat’ boxes encouraged small and regular donations throughout the day with a penny before each meal with grace.
Like rounding up at the till at the supermarket, or other shopping experiences, they offer a gentle and frequent opportunities to give.
3. Give yourself if you want to ask
‘Make some definite sacrifice yourself as your soldiers are sure to reflect your conduct’
The Officer, 1893
The peer to peer ask is a powerful one – when someone like you asks you to join them in also making a gift it invokes a social norm and shows that they are committed to it too.
If you want to be asking other people be a donor yourself. If you don’t care enough to give, in some small way, why should anyone else?
Also, being a donor to your charity (in whatever way you can) allows you to better understand the donor journey and what it feels like to be part of the supporter group, track the appeal and see when the letter or magazine lands on the doorstep and how quick and effective the thanking process really is.
4. Ethical products can also support mission
In 1891, playwright George Bernard Shaw and Fabian Society member Annie Besant were amongst others were campaigning against the Bryant and May match factories and their use of phosphorus in match production. The match girls went on strike to protest working conditions and the use of phosphorus in matches which resulted in ‘Phossy Jaw’ (a painful deterioration of the jaw and teeth caused by the phosphorus used in the match production process).
The Salvation Army created a new match factory that did not use phosphorus and produced matches with better pay and processes – these were called Lights in Darkest England and were more expensive to purchase than other matches. They were promoted as a way of supporting the ethical production but the factory closed down after a year.
So not everything works – and it is important to fail fast if a new idea doesn’t work stop doing it.
How else can you give supporters a chance to live out and align with your values with other purchases?
5. Issues of ready cash & when to ask
William Booth preaching at a meeting
We might think the challenges are of cash giving are a modern problem. Post pandemic many shops and charitable donations only offer contactless donation opportunities.
But 140 years ago fundraisers were worrying about donors having cash on them and their ability to give at collection time.
“Well-to-do people seldom carry much money with them in their purses, and yet the best time to touch their hearts is under the mellowing influences of a meeting, when they will often give twice as much as they would when they get home, or under other ordinary circumstances’
How can we make it easy for people to donate if they don’t have cash on them? Or if they only have cash is only accepting contactless donations stopping them giving?
This also speaks to the best time to make the ask – when they are emotionally engaged and warm to the ask, when they have been inspired by your cause.
When do you ask donors for a gift? When you have ‘touch[ed] their heart’ are really inspired them or when they are in ‘other ordinary circumstances’?
(To read more about Salvation Army fundraising fundamentals and innovations read this article https://marinajones.uk/salvationarmy/)
https://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/11/IMG_9403-3-scaled.jpeg18382560adminhttps://marinajones.uk/wp-content/uploads/2022/12/f2b903e010104f5aa61ea1821a685913.pngadmin2024-01-18 09:11:232024-01-18 10:21:015 More fundraising firsts and fundamentals from the Salvation Army archives
We may request cookies to be set on your device. We use cookies to let us know when you visit our websites, how you interact with us, to enrich your user experience, and to customize your relationship with our website.
Click on the different category headings to find out more. You can also change some of your preferences. Note that blocking some types of cookies may impact your experience on our websites and the services we are able to offer.
Essential Website Cookies
These cookies are strictly necessary to provide you with services available through our website and to use some of its features.
Because these cookies are strictly necessary to deliver the website, refusing them will have impact how our site functions. You always can block or delete cookies by changing your browser settings and force blocking all cookies on this website. But this will always prompt you to accept/refuse cookies when revisiting our site.
We fully respect if you want to refuse cookies but to avoid asking you again and again kindly allow us to store a cookie for that. You are free to opt out any time or opt in for other cookies to get a better experience. If you refuse cookies we will remove all set cookies in our domain.
We provide you with a list of stored cookies on your computer in our domain so you can check what we stored. Due to security reasons we are not able to show or modify cookies from other domains. You can check these in your browser security settings.
Google Analytics Cookies
These cookies collect information that is used either in aggregate form to help us understand how our website is being used or how effective our marketing campaigns are, or to help us customize our website and application for you in order to enhance your experience.
If you do not want that we track your visit to our site you can disable tracking in your browser here:
Other external services
We also use different external services like Google Webfonts, Google Maps, and external Video providers. Since these providers may collect personal data like your IP address we allow you to block them here. Please be aware that this might heavily reduce the functionality and appearance of our site. Changes will take effect once you reload the page.
Google Webfont Settings:
Google Map Settings:
Google reCaptcha Settings:
Vimeo and Youtube video embeds:
Other cookies
The following cookies are also needed - You can choose if you want to allow them:
Privacy Policy
You can read about our cookies and privacy settings in detail on our Privacy Policy Page.